The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Social studies. The lowest is 19% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Martin Road Elementary School
Martin Road Elementary sits on Martin Road in Lackawanna, a small Erie County city directly south of Buffalo that grew up around what was once one of the largest steel plants in the country. The plant's closure decades ago left a deep economic scar, and the city has spent years rebuilding around services, health care, and a gradual industrial revival on the former brownfield along Lake Erie. Publicly reported accounts describe Lackawanna as one of the faster-growing cities in New York in recent years, with homes selling quickly and above assessed value, a dynamic that contrasts with the city's working-class identity and still-modest housing prices. Compared to state and national benchmarks, the local housing market remains quite affordable, and Erie County as a whole has seen a meaningful increase in active listings recently, giving buyers more options than a year ago.
The school serves grades two through five, which is the first thing to understand about its state assessment results: grade two is not tested under New York's system, so the data covers grades three through five only. On the New York State Testing Program, proficiency rates in both English language arts and math are low across all three tested grades. In ELA, roughly one in five students reached the proficient-or-above threshold in third grade, with fourth and fifth grade rates somewhat higher but still well below a quarter of students. Math follows a similar pattern, with fourth grade posting the strongest result but still leaving the large majority of students below proficiency. Science, tested at fifth grade, shows a comparable picture. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile relative to districts in Erie County. These are the reported figures, and parents will reasonably want to discuss with the school what academic supports are in place and how the district is addressing the gap. Multi-year trend data was not available in what was provided, so it is not possible to say from this data whether results are improving, holding, or declining.
The student body is racially and ethnically mixed, with white students making up the largest group, followed by Hispanic and Black students, with smaller Asian and multiracial populations. The share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch is very high, placing the school in clearly high-poverty territory. Data on special education rates and English learner populations was not reported in what was provided.
Enrollment across the four grades is sizeable for a single elementary building, meaning classrooms are well-populated and the school has the critical mass for grade-level teams, multiple sections per grade, and the kind of peer variety that comes with a larger school. Program details beyond state-tested academics were not available in the data.
One structural change matters directly to families: publicly reported information from the district indicates that as part of a capital improvement project now under construction, fifth grade students will be relocated from Martin Road to the McKinley building. That means a family whose child is currently in grades two through four at Martin Road should expect their fifth-grade year to happen at a different site. Parents weighing this school should confirm the timeline and logistics of that transition directly with the district. The broader capital project is also delivering facility upgrades across district buildings, including secured entries, renovated spaces, and new athletic infrastructure at the middle and high school level.
Lackawanna itself offers civic anchors that many residents value: the Our Lady of Victory Basilica draws visitors from across the region, Olmsted-designed South Park and the Buffalo and Erie County Botanical Gardens are walkable from the city's central corridor, and NFTA bus service connects residents to the wider Buffalo metro. The city is car-dependent for most daily errands, though the Ridge Road corridor functions as a genuine neighborhood commercial spine. For families drawn to an affordable, diverse, historically rooted community within easy reach of Buffalo, Lackawanna's setting is a concrete asset. The academic performance at Martin Road is an area where the school and district have real work ahead.
See more original research from School Decision →