The top reported proficiency rate is 71% in Math. The lowest is 67% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on John a Sciole Elementary School
John A. Sciole Elementary School serves kindergarten through third grade in Depew, a compact post-war suburb east of Buffalo. The school sits on a campus setting apart from the village's civic core, located on Transit Road away from the Olmsted-planned civic spine and green spaces that define the community's center.
The school enrollment is small to mid-sized for its grade band, with a relatively stable population across the four grades. About a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a community with working families but not one facing widespread economic hardship. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller populations of Asian, Hispanic, and other students; specific data on English learners and students with individualized education plans were not available.
In the most recent year tested, third-grade proficiency in math stood near the district average, with about seven in ten students meeting or exceeding the state standard. Reading proficiency was slightly lower, with about two-thirds of third graders proficient. These results place the school in the top quartile of proficiency across districts in Erie County when looking at overall performance across tested subjects and grades, a meaningful position that reflects solid teaching and learning. Testing participation rates were high, indicating reliable results.
The school sits at the center of a significant district expansion. Voters approved a major capital improvement project in 2024 that includes adding about twenty-five classrooms across all four elementary schools in the district, including Sciole. Construction is set to begin in late 2025 and continue for several years. This reflects the district's response to enrollment growth and means families here should anticipate building activity and classroom expansion over the next several years. The referendum carries local tax-rate implications phased over time.
Depew itself is largely built out, with little room for new housing; the community focuses on revitalizing existing homes and repurposing underused land. Housing values are modest, and rental costs are moderate relative to county benchmarks. Employment anchors include manufacturing, health care, and retail, with firms like AMETEK Reichert headquartered locally. The village has invested in pedestrian infrastructure and treats Terrace Boulevard, a tree-lined Olmsted-designed street, as its civic anchor, though commercial corridors remain car-oriented. The Amtrak station and NFTA bus routes connect the area to Buffalo and the airport.
The school offers a straightforward elementary experience in a community-oriented district undergoing growth and capital investment. A parent may want to look into current classroom capacity and ask the school directly about how the expansion timeline may affect class sizes and program continuity in the near term.
See more original research from School Decision →