The top reported proficiency rate is 94% in Science. The lowest is 64% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Mount Sinai Elementary School
Mount Sinai Elementary School serves kindergarten through fourth grade in a quiet, tree-lined residential hamlet on Long Island's North Shore. The school is a regular public elementary school enrolling a typical mid-sized population for its grade band, drawn from a community that is overwhelmingly single-family homes and known for a close-knit neighborhood texture. The school sits on a consolidated campus with the district's middle and high schools at North Country Road, separate from the Route 25A commercial strip that anchors most local business activity.
The student body is predominantly white, with Hispanic students making up a meaningful minority, and smaller populations of Asian and biracial students. A modest share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a generally middle-income enrollment, though Mount Sinai does include economic diversity. The enrollment across the kindergarten through fourth grade span is relatively balanced, with each grade representing a stable cohort within the overall population. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available.
Recent state testing results show mathematics proficiency above the midpoint among Suffolk County districts overall, with students in fourth grade outperforming those in third grade. In English language arts, fourth grade proficiency is solid and above the midpoint countywide, while third grade proficiency sits lower. A science assessment from the 2021-22 school year showed notably strong results. Across tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile relative to other Suffolk County districts. The participation rates on state assessments are modest—in the range of about half to mid-sixties across grades and subjects—which is a characteristic some parents may want to look into further with the school to understand whether absences or other factors play a role.
Mount Sinai itself is a residential hamlet with no traditional downtown center; civic and recreational life is anchored at the school campus, Heritage Park and the Heritage Center, and Cedar Beach, a town park on the harbor with walking trails and recreational amenities. The hamlet functions as a car-dependent suburb with shopping and dining strung along Route 25A. Transit options are limited; the nearest Long Island Rail Road access is in nearby Port Jefferson.
The district has recently made investments in its future. Voters approved a substantial capital bond referendum in September 2025 for district-wide safety and security upgrades, modernized learning environments, roadway and parking-lot reconstruction, and a new turf field. Because Mount Sinai is a residential community with a limited commercial tax base, the bond carries a lasting tax impact on homeowners. The district is also launching a New York State Universal Pre-Kindergarten program in September 2026, offering free, full-week public preschool to families with younger children. The district's adopted strategic plan, Mustang Pride: Building Our Future 2030, prioritizes teaching and learning, wellness, and student experience, with expansions planned in career pathways, dual enrollment, and computer science. These initiatives reflect a district positioning itself for growth and deeper academic programming as students advance through the system.
See more original research from School Decision →