The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in Math. The lowest is 0% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Putnam Valley Elementary School
Putnam Valley Elementary School serves kindergarten through fourth grade in a small, residential Hudson Highlands town about an hour north of New York City. The school enrolls roughly mid-sized numbers within the rural setting, with nearly a quarter of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Hispanic enrollment, and smaller numbers of Asian, Black, and multiracial students. Data on special education and English learner counts were not available, so parents may want to ask the school directly about support structures for those populations.
The school's academic performance shows solid proficiency in both math and English language arts for the grades it tests. In third grade, the majority of students score at proficient or advanced levels in both subjects. Fourth grade proficiency rates remain strong across both areas. Fifth-grade results are not available because the school does not serve that grade; the state tests fifth grade as part of the elementary testing window, but students move to the middle school before taking those assessments.
Among the six districts in Putnam County, this school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. This comparison reflects that the school's current results, while showing competent teaching and learning in core subjects, run below the district average in the county. Parents should understand this in context: the school serves a community with lower overall proficiency than some neighboring districts, and the mix of absolute performance and relative positioning suggests this is a straightforward elementary program rather than one with unusual academic strength. A conversation with the school about what's working, what population challenges exist, and how student support is structured would help families understand whether the environment meets their child's needs.
The school sits in Putnam Valley proper, a low-density, wooded town where most residents own homes and commercial activity is sparse. Housing values in the area sit well above the state average. The town is zoned and planned explicitly to preserve its rural character, with large minimum lot sizes and limited commercial intensity. Growth is slow and deliberate. This is a car-dependent setting; there is no walkable downtown core, and families drive to retail in neighboring towns. Public transit is limited; the nearest Metro-North stations are in adjacent communities. The landscape includes Clarence Fahnestock Memorial State Park, which runs through the area with hiking, a lake beach, and trails, and the Putnam Valley Free Library serves as a civic anchor.
The district has undergone significant recent change. After voters narrowly rejected a capital plan in early 2025, the district returned with a revised, smaller-scale proposal that passed in May. This approved spending will fund facility upgrades across the school years ahead, including renovation of the elementary library and nurse's suite, new playground equipment for younger grades, and ongoing conversion to geothermal heating and cooling. The construction work will shape the school environment for several years. The district is in the middle of a multi-year, system-wide shift to fossil-fuel independence, with the elementary school now completing its conversion to ground-source heating and solar panels being added at the high school campus. This sustainability investment reduces long-term operating costs and has drawn recognition from the state for environmental achievement.
For families considering this school, the picture is of a stable, competent elementary program in a quiet, family-oriented residential community. The academic performance is solid but not exceptional relative to its county peers. The setting is rural, scenic, and requires driving for most daily needs. The recent bond approval and ongoing facility work mean the physical campus will change over the coming years. This fits families seeking a small-town, nature-adjacent elementary experience with straightforward academics and willing to accept a car-dependent lifestyle and below-average county-level proficiency outcomes.
See more original research from School Decision →