The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Science. The lowest is 56% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on David B Crane Elementary School
David B Crane Elementary serves kindergarten through third grade in Rochester, part of the Rush-Henrietta Central School District. The school sits in a residential area of a city that has been reinventing itself after decades of population loss. For families weighing this school, the academic picture is mixed, the setting is urban with accessible housing, and the district context carries some recent tension worth understanding.
On academics, the school's most recent state testing shows proficiency in math running at roughly two-thirds of students, while English language arts trails at just above half. Both sit below where they might ideally be for early elementary, and a parent should ask the school directly about the factors behind these results and what support systems exist for students who are not yet meeting grade-level benchmarks. An older science result from the upper grades served by this school showed very strong performance, though that data is years old and cannot be read as current. The school participates fully in state testing, which is a positive sign of transparency. Across tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among districts in Monroe County, a meaningful strength.
The enrollment is small for its grades, around three hundred fifty students spread across four grade bands. A bit more than half the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is racially diverse, with roughly equal shares of white, Asian, Black, and multiracial or Hispanic students. The diversity itself is neither strength nor weakness; what matters is whether the school builds on it thoughtfully. The school has no data publicly available on special education or English learner populations, so a prospective family would want to inquire about those support systems directly.
The housing market in the 14623 zip code shows homes in the mid-range for the region, with rental costs aligning roughly with national averages. The market has been active, with growing inventory and median listing prices that have moved upward gradually. Property taxes in Rush-Henrietta are consistently among the lowest in Monroe County when adjusted for true value, a factor that shapes affordability alongside housing prices. However, the district's recent budget history is worth noting: the initial 2024-25 budget failed by a narrow margin before the board revised it downward and secured voter approval on a second attempt. This signals community watchfulness over school spending, which some families view as healthy governance and others as a sign of fiscal tension. For 2025-26, a town property reassessment led to an estimated tax-rate decrease despite a rising levy, a quirk of the reassessment process that improved the immediate tax picture.
Rochester itself is a mixed urban environment. The city has undergone significant downtown revitalization over the past decade, with adaptive-reuse housing, new affordable developments, and public reinvestment including the partial fill-in of an old urban expressway. Frederick Law Olmsted-designed parks anchor the city, and the downtown core is walkable and mixed-use. The economy centers on healthcare, higher education, and advanced manufacturing, with major employers including the University of Rochester Medical Center, Xerox, Rochester Institute of Technology, and regional hospitals. The city offers the cultural anchors and street life of a regional center, though economic recovery is ongoing.
For a family choosing an elementary school at this site, the questions to ask are about reading and math support systems, the quality of early literacy instruction, how the school uses its diverse student body as an asset, and what the school community actually looks like day to day. The school's location in an urban district with solid resources but moderate academic results, combined with housing that is accessible and tax rates that are favorable by local comparison, makes this a fit for families seeking urban proximity, community diversity, and moderate costs who are prepared to be engaged consumers of what their school offers.
See more original research from School Decision →