The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in English language arts. The lowest is 17% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on H Frank Carey High School
H. Frank Carey High School sits on Poppy Avenue in Franklin Square, a postwar Long Island hamlet in the Town of Hempstead. The school serves grades seven through twelve and draws from a densely residential commuter community roughly twenty miles east of Manhattan, characterized by tree-lined blocks of single-family homes, a walkable commercial spine along Hempstead Turnpike, and no formal downtown core. Franklin Square is largely built out, with new housing arriving mostly as scattered teardowns and infill rather than large subdivisions. Home values here run well above the New York state median and have continued rising; the Nassau County market broadly reflects that pressure, with homes moving relatively quickly in spring and prices per square foot climbing year over year. Buying into this attendance zone carries a meaningful cost commitment.
Carey is a mid-to-large secondary school for its grade band, enrolling students across all six grade levels from seventh through twelfth. The student body is majority white, with Hispanic students forming the next largest group and a meaningful share of Asian students as well. The share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch is modest relative to many suburban schools. Data on English learner rates and students with IEPs was not available in the provided records.
On state assessments, the picture is uneven and worth understanding carefully. Seventh-grade math proficiency is solid, with a clear majority of tested students reaching the proficient-or-above threshold. Seventh-grade ELA and eighth-grade ELA sit in a similar range, with roughly half to slightly above half of tested students reaching proficiency. Eighth-grade math and eighth-grade science proficiency are markedly lower, with only a small fraction of tested students meeting the standard. Parents will want to ask the school directly about these eighth-grade results, particularly in math and science, and what supports or course-placement structures are in place for that cohort.
One important context note: the participation rates in the grade-eight assessments are very low, far below normal testing participation. When only a small slice of a grade sits for an exam, the proficiency figure reflects that narrow group rather than the full grade, and results can swing sharply. Whether that reflects students taking accelerated courses assessed differently, opt-out patterns, or another factor is not clear from the data, and a parent would be well served asking the school for clarification before drawing conclusions.
Placed against other districts in Nassau County, Carey's overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quartile of the comparison set. Nassau County contains dozens of districts with widely varying demographics and resources, so that position reflects where this school currently sits within a competitive county peer group.
Graduation rate data was not available in the records provided.
The parent district, Sewanhaka Central High School District, has made several publicly reported changes in recent years that affect Carey directly. The district has expanded dual-enrollment college credit courses, added Project Lead the Way STEM electives, introduced a new English as a New Language program, implemented co-teaching in ENL and special education settings, and rolled out district-wide midterms aimed at strengthening Regents exam outcomes. These are real expansions of the academic pathway available to students. Voters also recently approved a capital reserve fund earmarked partly for air conditioning in the district's high school auditoriums, giving the district a standing mechanism to fund facility upgrades from surplus without new debt. The district adopted a formal AI policy in 2025. Program offerings specific to Carey beyond the district-level picture were not available in the data provided.
For a family weighing Franklin Square as a place to settle, the combination of an expensive and appreciating housing market, a suburban community with reasonable walkability near its commercial corridor, LIRR access at nearby Garden City and Stewart Manor, and a secondary school with growing academic programs but uneven state test results is the honest summary. Families who prioritize dual-enrollment and STEM pathway expansion will find recent district moves in that direction; families focused on tested proficiency outcomes, especially in eighth-grade math and science, will want a fuller conversation with the school before drawing conclusions from what the current data shows.
See more original research from School Decision →