The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Social studies. The lowest is 39% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Silver Creek Elementary School
Silver Creek Elementary School is the pre-kindergarten through fifth grade school serving the Silver Creek Central School District, sitting on the district's consolidated Dickinson Street campus alongside the middle and high schools. The village it anchors is a small Lake Erie shore community in Chautauqua County, historically a port town now surrounded by the Concord Grape Belt. Homes here are modest in price relative to state and national benchmarks, well below the New York state average, and the Chautauqua County market has seen a notable jump in active listings and pending sales over the past year, suggesting a busier market than recent years. A family buying into this attendance zone is entering an affordable housing market, though one with some movement.
The school draws a student body that is predominantly white, with meaningful shares of Hispanic and American Indian or Alaska Native students, and a smaller representation of multiracial children. Roughly half the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places economic need squarely in the middle of what the school serves. Data on English learner counts and students with IEPs were not available in what was provided.
State assessment results from the New York State Testing Program give the clearest picture of academic performance. In math, third and fifth graders reached proficiency at rates that are solid, with most students testing at the proficient-or-above level in those grades. Fourth grade math was weaker, with fewer than half of students reaching proficiency. In English language arts, results were more consistently below the midpoint across all three tested grades, with third, fourth, and fifth graders each reaching proficiency at rates in the high thirties to low forties. Fifth grade science results were similar in range to ELA. Placed against districts in Chautauqua County, the school's overall proficiency index sits above the county median, which means it compares reasonably well within its local peer group even as the raw numbers leave room for growth. Parents who want to understand how individual grade cohorts are progressing, and what supports exist for students who are not yet proficient, would do well to ask the school directly. Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible from this data to say whether results are improving, holding, or declining.
The district itself has some meaningful changes underway. Voters recently approved a capital project described publicly as the largest in district history, funding renovated classrooms, auditorium and pool improvements, a new playground, and a new outdoor multi-sport field. Publicly reported accounts indicate the project carries no property tax increase for residents because it draws on a capital reserve fund and state aid reimbursement. A separate operating budget for the coming school year does include a modest property tax levy increase, and district officials have been explicit that the two are distinct. For a family thinking about what the district will look like physically over the next few years, construction is actively underway.
One day-to-day change worth knowing: starting in the 2025-26 school year, New York State requires a bell-to-bell ban on student smartphones and personal internet-enabled devices during the school day. Silver Creek implemented this per state mandate, with the standard exceptions for medical needs and IEP requirements.
The village itself is compact, with tree-lined streets, sidewalks, older housing stock in styles ranging from Craftsman bungalows to Colonial Revivals, and direct Lake Erie access at George Borello Park and a Jackson Street boat launch. The Anderson-Lee Library on Main Street is part of the county library system and provides public internet access. The annual Festival of Grapes is a community anchor each September. Downtown commercial activity is limited but present, and a number of residents commute to Dunkirk, Fredonia, or the Buffalo area for work. A significant redevelopment is also underway downtown: the long-vacant former high school building at 60 Main Street is being demolished and replaced with a new senior affordable housing complex, a project supported by county, state, and village funding sources, with demolition having begun in 2025.
Program details beyond the core academic subjects were not available in the data provided, so it is not possible to characterize extracurricular offerings, special programs, or staffing ratios at the elementary level. A parent should ask the school directly about enrichment, interventions, and what structured supports exist for students who need additional help in reading and math.
See more original research from School Decision →