The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 69% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Dogwood Elementary School
Dogwood Elementary is a public school serving children from kindergarten through fifth grade in Smithtown, a suburban residential town on Long Island's North Shore, part of the Smithtown Central School District. The school enrolls students from across a range of racial and ethnic backgrounds; the majority of the school is White, with Hispanic students making up the next largest group, and smaller populations of Asian, multiracial, and other students. Fewer than one in ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating that the school serves a largely middle-to-upper-income community.
On state assessments administered in 2024-25, Dogwood's proficiency outcomes show a pattern that warrants close attention. In third grade, roughly two-thirds of students tested achieved proficiency in both math and English language arts, with math slightly higher. Fourth grade dropped notably lower in both subjects, with just over half the students reaching proficiency in English language arts and a little under two-thirds in math. Fifth grade rebounded; about four-fifths of students met the proficiency bar in English language arts, and roughly the same share in math. In fifth-grade science, about seven in ten students were proficient. These year-to-year shifts suggest that fourth grade is a pressure point, and parents may want to look into what pedagogical or support factors explain the dip and whether the school has targeted initiatives to shore up performance there. Across the county's school districts, Dogwood's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile, meaning its average performance across subjects and grades ranks among the stronger performers in Suffolk County.
Test participation rates in the upper grades were somewhat lower than ideal, ranging from seven in ten to about three-quarters of students taking the exams, particularly in fourth grade where participation dipped to seven in ten. Parents considering the school should ask whether these absences on test day reflect documented illness or scheduling conflicts, or whether they signal broader attendance challenges worth monitoring.
The school is nestled in a community with a strong real estate market. Home values in the zip code are substantial, and have moved upward year over year. Rental units are also available and have similarly risen. The broader Suffolk County housing market is showing increased inventory and more moderate market conditions than existed a year prior, though listing prices and competition remain steady.
Smithtown itself is a car-oriented suburban town anchored by six hamlets, with Main Street downtown as a walkable retail and civic center. The Long Island Rail Road serves three stations in or near the area, connecting residents to Manhattan. The town has extensive parkland, including Caleb Smith State Park Preserve along the Nissequogue River, and is undergoing a downtown revitalization effort centered on transit-oriented mixed-use development around the Kings Park LIRR station. The district is investing in building infrastructure through a major bond program approved in 2021 for system-wide upgrades to HVAC, fire safety, windows, and structural repairs, with no planned property tax increase tied to the bond. However, the district's property tax levy has been set at the maximum allowable amount under New York's tax cap in recent budget cycles, including for 2025-26 and 2026-27, so families relocating should understand that property tax burden is structured toward the upper limits of what the law allows. The district also serves the hamlets of St. James, Kings Park, and Nesconset.
Dogwood Elementary is a regular public school with no charter or magnet designation. Data on special education enrollment, English learner services, and disciplinary practices were not available. Enrollment is modest, around the expected size for an elementary school of this grade band in a suburban district. The school represents a mainstream suburban educational pathway in a stable, relatively affluent community undergoing measured development and tax pressure that a prospective family should weigh alongside strong peer academic outcomes overall.
See more original research from School Decision →