The top reported proficiency rate is 18% in Math. The lowest is 13% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Summit Park Elementary School
Summit Park Elementary School is a small public school serving kindergarten through third grade in New City, part of the East Ramapo Central School District (Spring Valley). The school sits on a suburban campus away from New City's downtown civic core and serves a student population that is heavily economically disadvantaged and predominantly Hispanic and Black.
The enrollment hovers around that size across four grade levels, with roughly seven in ten students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Racially and ethnically, the student body is approximately four in five Hispanic, one in seven Black, and smaller shares of other backgrounds. Data on special education and English language learner populations were not available, though the district as a whole is roughly one in three English language learners, a detail worth asking the school about directly given the school's demographics.
On state math and reading assessments for third graders in 2024-25, results were low. Math proficiency hovered near one in five, with the average student scoring at a scale score well below what the state considers proficient. Reading proficiency was even lower, at roughly one in eight. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Rockland County. For context, the median school in the county's comparison set shows proficiency around three times higher. School participation in testing was near-universal in math and strong in reading, so the results reflect actual performance rather than missing data. These are numbers a parent may want to explore further with the school directly, asking what root causes the staff identifies, what supports are in place for struggling readers and mathematicians, and what the trajectory looks like over time.
New City itself is an affluent suburban commuter hamlet and the county seat, roughly a half-hour drive north of Manhattan. The area has transformed from rural land after World War II into a populated suburb, anchored by county government offices, shopping, and civic institutions like the New City Library downtown along Main Street. The housing market is solid, with home values well above state and national benchmarks and modest year-over-year appreciation. Mortgage costs are steep relative to median household income, a key factor for families relocating here.
The district is in the midst of two major shifts. First, the state forced through the district's first property-tax levy increase in roughly a decade for 2024-25, adding material pressure on homeowner school taxes after a long freeze. Second, the district is overhauling literacy instruction across all grades, adopting the science-of-reading approach mandated by the state and moving away from balanced literacy, a pedagogy change that will reshape how every child learns to read starting in the 2025-26 school year. The district is retraining teachers and acquiring new materials to support this transition.
The district also remains under expanded state-monitor oversight, meaning major budgets, financial plans, and board policies require state approval, an unusual governance structure that stems from years of prior fiscal and governance challenges. Parents evaluating the district should understand this oversight model as context for how decisions get made.
For a family at Summit Park, the fit depends on whether parents prioritize proximity to an economically and racially diverse student body, are comfortable with a school where academic proficiency is substantially below county peers, and are willing to engage with the district's current instructional overhaul and fiscal dynamics. The school and district offer what they offer; the questions are whether it aligns with a family's expectations and capacity to partner with the school on student support.
See more original research from School Decision →