The top reported proficiency rate is 97% in Social studies. The lowest is 46% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Montebello Road School
Montebello Road School sits on Montebello Road in Suffern, New York, part of the Suffern Central School District in Rockland County. It serves grades three through five only, which is a recent and deliberate change. Starting in the 2024-25 school year, the district reorganized its elementary buildings into a grade-banded structure publicly described as a modified Princeton Model: two schools now handle prekindergarten through second grade, and two, including Montebello, handle third through fifth. Families entering the district should expect their child to move buildings between second and third grade rather than staying in one K-5 school for all of elementary. The district publicly attributed this restructuring to a meaningful decline in elementary enrollment as a growing share of families in the area choose private or religious schools.
Because Montebello now begins at grade three, there are no state assessment results for kindergarten through second grade, which is expected given that New York does not test those grades. The results that do exist cover third, fourth, and fifth grade in English language arts, math, and fifth-grade science. Across all three subjects and grades, proficiency rates run roughly in the low-to-upper fifties, with fourth grade performing somewhat better than third or fifth in both ELA and math, and fifth-grade science coming in a bit lower than the other subjects. Placed against the nine districts in Rockland County, Montebello's overall proficiency index lands just below the midpoint of that group. That is a plain read, not a verdict: it means there are both stronger- and weaker-performing district peers in the county, and the school is closer to the lower half of that range than the upper. Parents who want to understand how individual subgroups are performing, or whether specific grades are trending, should ask the school directly, as multi-year trend data was not available in what was provided here.
Enrollment is split fairly evenly across the three grade levels. The student body is majority Hispanic, with white students forming the next largest group, followed by Black and Asian students, and smaller shares of other backgrounds. Free and reduced-price lunch eligibility data was not reported in the source material, so economic context for the student population here is a gap. The district does offer a 50/50 two-way English-Spanish dual language enrichment program starting in kindergarten, and the 2025-26 budget publicly extends it to additional grade levels; families enrolled in that strand would continue into Montebello when they reach third grade. The district has also publicly described a district-wide shift to Science of Reading-based literacy instruction.
The school is a regular public school with no charter or magnet designation. Title I status was not reported. Chronic absenteeism and disciplinary data were not available in what was provided.
The surrounding community is Suffern, a compact incorporated village in Rockland County, sitting roughly thirty miles northwest of Manhattan near the New York-New Jersey state line. Publicly reported information describes a walkable downtown along Lafayette Avenue with local restaurants and shops anchored by a historic Art Deco theater, alongside a commuter rail station that serves both NJ Transit and Metro-North lines, making the village a genuine transit hub for New York City commuters. The dominant local employer is a large regional hospital. Harriman State Park, one of the largest in New York State, borders the village and offers extensive outdoor access.
Housing costs here are well above both state and national medians, and the price-to-income ratio places the market in demanding territory. Rents are also high relative to income. The village is largely built out, with recent residential development concentrated on downtown rental and condo properties near the train station. Annual school budgets have passed with strong voter support, and the district publicly reports holding its tax levy at or below the state cap, which is relevant context for families thinking about long-term property tax exposure.
A parent choosing this school is choosing a grades-three-through-five building within a recently restructured district, a predominantly Hispanic peer community, a dual-language program option, and a housing market that prices in the premium of Rockland County's proximity to New York City.
See more original research from School Decision →