The top reported proficiency rate is 64% in Social studies. The lowest is 17% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Meachem Elementary School
Meachem Elementary School is a small public elementary school in Syracuse serving prekindergarten through fifth grade, located in a historically African American neighborhood on the city's south side. With an enrollment drawn heavily from low-income households, the school sits at the center of the region's current economic transition, as Syracuse and Central New York prepare for major growth tied to semiconductor manufacturing.
The school's academic standing presents a clear challenge. Across tested grades and subjects, student proficiency rates are low. In mathematics, third-grade proficiency sits in the teens, fourth-grade approaches one-third, and fifth-grade reaches roughly the same level. In English language arts, performance is similar or softer, with fourth-grade proficiency in the high teens and third and fifth grades closer to one-quarter. Science proficiency at the fifth-grade level is in the low teens. Placed against other districts in Onondaga County, Meachem's overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quartile. These results reflect genuine academic pressure that prospective families should understand as a starting point for any school choice decision. A parent may want to discuss with the school directly what interventions and supports are in place and what trajectory the school anticipates.
Demographically, the school is predominantly Black, with a substantial share of students identifying as Hispanic or multiracial, and a very small representation of white and Asian students. Nearly nine in ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating concentrated economic hardship. The enrollment is small for the grade band, with individual grades ranging from just over a few dozen to roughly mid-range numbers. Specific counts of students with disabilities or English learners were not available in the data provided.
The school sits within the Syracuse City School District, which covers the city proper. The district has recently made several investments and changes relevant to families. The opening of a new STEAM (Science, Technology, Arts and Math) High School in fall 2025 in a renovated downtown building gives high school students an option focused on semiconductor microchip technology, robotics, animation, and construction management, tied to Micron's planned regional manufacturing campus. The district also recognized Eid al-Fitr as an observed school holiday beginning in 2023, reflecting its diverse student body that includes a substantial refugee and Muslim population. A third phase of the state-funded Joint Schools Construction Board program is financing renovations across city schools, with state reimbursement covering much of the cost, limiting local tax burden and bringing facility upgrades to multiple buildings over time.
The broader Syracuse housing market is active and shifting. Home values in the school's zip code have appreciated modestly year-over-year, and the county real estate market shows strong demand paired with moderate supply; median listing prices have declined recently while pending listings have grown. The city itself is entering a growth phase driven by Micron's planned investment and associated housing development, including the major redevelopment of the former Syracuse Developmental Center into thousands of new affordable and market-rate apartments. This growth context may reshape housing costs and neighborhood composition over the coming years.
For a family considering Meachem, the essential question is whether the school's documented academic gaps can be addressed through targeted support or change, and whether the family has capacity and resources to augment learning at home or through other means. The school's student body is economically stressed and racially concentrated. The school operates within a district that is actively investing in new programs and facilities. The neighborhood and broader region are entering a transition period that may bring both opportunity and displacement pressure.
See more original research from School Decision →