The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Social studies. The lowest is 51% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Forest Lake School
Forest Lake School is a PreK through grade 5 public elementary school in Wantagh, Nassau County, serving a modestly sized enrollment from the surrounding residential neighborhood. The school is part of the Wantagh Union Free School District, a long-established suburban district on Long Island's South Shore.
The school's academic picture shows strength in math at the lower grades, with students in grade 3 showing proficiency rates well above the midpoint, and grade 4 remaining strong. Performance softens progressively from grade 4 into grade 5, where proficiency drops more noticeably in both math and English language arts. English language arts follows a similar arc: solid in grade 4, but substantially weaker by grade 5. Science proficiency in grade 5 sits below the midpoint. Overall, Forest Lake's proficiency index places it above the midpoint among the county's districts, a positive measure, though the downward trend across grades and the softer results in grade 5 suggest that upper-elementary performance warrants attention. A parent may want to look into what supports the school provides for grade 5 students or what transitions occur as children move toward middle school.
The school enrolled a diverse mix, with white students forming the clear majority and a smaller but meaningful share of Hispanic, Asian, and other racial and ethnic backgrounds. Free- or reduced-price lunch eligibility was low, indicating an overall affluent student population, though a small number of students do qualify for meal support. The district provides a grant-funded Universal PreK program with full-day, five-hour sessions in all three elementary schools, offering free early-childhood care to lottery-placed families, which expands access for working parents, though continuation depends on ongoing grant funding.
Wantagh itself is a built-out, long-established suburban hamlet on Nassau County's South Shore, known informally as the Gateway to Jones Beach. It is predominantly residential and family-oriented, anchored by local parks, the public library, and the Wantagh LIRR station on the Babylon Branch, which provides commuter rail access to New York. The neighborhood has limited new rental construction and reflects a mature, incrementally growing market. Median home values in the 11793 zip code are substantial, reflecting the affluent character of the community, and housing inventory has tightened relative to demand. The area is car-oriented despite walkable residential blocks near the commercial core; schools sit on suburban campuses within neighborhoods rather than in the downtown cluster around the station.
The district recently invested in facility upgrades through a 2022 bond referendum that passed two of three propositions. Work includes replacing aging windows and ventilation systems, upgrading athletic fields at Forest Lake Elementary, adding new playground equipment, and renovating the high school's library and cafeteria. These improvements signal a commitment to facilities maintenance that families moving into the district may factor into their decision. The district also approved a proposal to sell a property on Beech Street to a developer for single-family home construction, reflecting decisions about the district's long-term physical footprint.
Forest Lake fits families seeking a stable, affluent suburban community with rail access to the city, modest class sizes in the elementary grades, and a neighborhood school setting. The profile suggests a school where early elementary performance is sound but where upper-grade academics may benefit from closer monitoring or additional support for students transitioning into middle school.
See more original research from School Decision →