The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Science. The lowest is 44% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Sherman School
Sherman School serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Watertown, a mid-sized city in Jefferson County in upstate New York's North Country. The school enrolls students across all five grade bands, with enrollment distributed fairly evenly from kindergarten through fourth grade. More than half of Sherman's students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student population is predominantly white, with smaller shares of students identifying as multiracial, Hispanic, Asian, and Black.
The most recent state testing data available shows proficiency rates in both English language arts and mathematics that fall below the midpoint when compared to other districts in Jefferson County. In third-grade math, proficiency sits at around half of students meeting the standard. Fourth-grade performance dips further, with math proficiency below that rate and ELA proficiency also in the lower range. Science data from an earlier year showed stronger results, with a majority of fourth graders meeting proficiency. The school's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint for the county. Student participation in testing is strong across subjects, suggesting results reflect genuine performance rather than absences or opt-outs.
Watertown itself is the county seat and functions as the region's retail, healthcare, education, and recreation hub. Downtown centers on Public Square, a walkable historic district with restored late-19th and early-20th-century buildings housing mixed-use commercial and residential space. The broader area has experienced little population or employment growth in recent decades, but downtown has been the target of sustained reinvestment over roughly a decade. The economy leans on healthcare, retail, accommodation and food services, and is shaped considerably by proximity to Fort Drum military reservation. Housing values in the Watertown area are below state and national benchmarks; rental costs are moderate but have risen notably in the past year.
The Watertown City School District has recently undertaken two major shifts affecting families. In 2025, voters approved a substantial capital project to repair and revitalize the district's roughly ten aging buildings, addressing structural issues, roofing, windows, parking, classroom climate control, and playgrounds. The project is expected to proceed without increasing local property taxes. At the same time, the district's spending and local tax burden have risen sharply. The operating budget crossed into nine figures for the first time in 2025-26 and is scheduled to grow further in 2026-27, with a tax levy increase described as the highest in several years. For families considering a move to Watertown, the combination of facility upgrades and rising school taxes represents both an investment in physical plant and a direct cost to households.
Sherman is a regular public school without charter or magnet designation. Data on special education enrollment, English learner status, and other support services were not available. The school's website and additional program information were also not accessible, so a full picture of curriculum approach, extracurricular offerings, or specialized services could not be drawn from the available sources. A parent may want to contact the school or district directly to understand what academic and support services are available and how the school plans to improve the early proficiency gaps evident in the current testing data.
See more original research from School Decision →