The top reported proficiency rate is 18% in Math. The lowest is 9% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Buffalo Commons Charter School
Buffalo Commons Charter School is a young school still in its formative growth phase. It opened in 2022 serving kindergarten and first grade and is adding a grade level each year as it builds toward a full K-8 program. Currently it serves roughly the early elementary grades. Families considering this school should understand they are joining a school that is still maturing and scaling up, not an established multi-grade institution.
The school's enrollment has grown modestly since its founding. The student body is small but intentionally so: in a recent charter modification, the school sought to scale back its originally planned growth trajectory, which means class sizes and staffing are likely to reflect that scaled, smaller model going forward. A substantial share of the school's students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic profile of Buffalo's student population. The student body is predominantly Black, with smaller shares of white, Asian, and multiracial students.
On state testing, the school's results are weak. Third-grade students showed low proficiency rates in both English language arts and math on the 2024-25 state assessment. Only a small number of third graders reached proficiency in either subject. The participation rate was below full engagement, which means some students did not test, so reported proficiency reflects only those who participated. Among districts in Erie County, Buffalo Commons's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile relative to other district-level entities in the county. This is data parents may want to discuss directly with the school, particularly regarding instructional approach and support services for early learners.
Grade-by-grade enrollment data is not yet deep, and the school does not yet report staffing, discipline, or attendance metrics. Information on special education identification rates and English learner status was not available. Because the school serves only early elementary grades, there are no graduation rates or broader academic trajectory measures to examine. These gaps partly reflect the fact that the school is young and serving only K through second grade; state testing begins in third grade, so only the third-grade cohort has benchmark results.
Buffalo itself is an urban place with mixed neighborhoods, walkable commercial avenues, and historic housing stock. The downtown has undergone steady redevelopment toward mixed-use residential and commercial space, and surrounding neighborhoods like Allentown and Elmwood Village maintain street-level shops and restaurants. Public transit is available through the NFTA bus and Metro Rail system. Housing is older and varied: wood-frame singles and doubles, brick rowhouses, and converted loft and warehouse space, mostly rental or owner-occupied at moderate prices for the region.
Buffalo Commons participates in the unified Buffalo charter common application, which lets families apply to multiple charter schools through one form and deadline. This simplifies the logistics for parents weighing alternatives to Buffalo Public Schools. That said, parents enrolling now are signing up for a school that is still defining itself and proving its instructional model; they should be prepared to assess progress carefully over the first few years of their child's enrollment.
See more original research from School Decision →