The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in Science. The lowest is 19% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Madison Avenue School of Arts
Madison Avenue School of Arts is a public charter school on Madison Avenue in Toledo serving kindergarten through sixth grade, with plans to add eighth grade. The school enrolled roughly 400 students in the most recent school year, distributed fairly evenly across its grade span. The student body is predominantly Black, with smaller populations of multiracial and Hispanic students and a very small number of white and Native American students. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and special education enrollment were not available.
The school's academic results show low proficiency across tested subjects. In math, English language arts, and science for grades three through six, proficiency rates fall below one in five students across all three subjects. The school participates in state testing at high rates, indicating the results reflect actual student performance rather than incomplete testing. Science proficiency was somewhat higher than math and ELA, though still modest. The one available earlier data point, from social studies testing in 2016, showed similar low proficiency. On a proficiency index that averages performance across subjects and grades, Madison Avenue sits in the bottom quartile among the eight tested schools in Lucas County, well below the median performance in the county and among the lowest performing schools measured.
This is a school where academic proficiency is a real challenge that parents should expect and understand. If test-based achievement is a priority for your family, this would not be the right fit.
The school's identity and purpose, however, centers explicitly on arts and character education rather than test-driven academics. The school earned national recognition in 2024 as a National School of Character—the only Ohio school honored that way that year—reflecting a sustained emphasis on character education that shapes daily culture. An arts focus anchors the curriculum and experience. These commitments are meaningful and distinct and may appeal to families who value social-emotional and creative development as essential parts of schooling.
The school is expanding. A board meeting was scheduled for 2026 to discuss adding eighth grade, which would extend the pathway for families who want to keep a child enrolled longer before transitioning to a traditional middle or secondary setting. Housing in the school's zip code, 43604, is relatively affordable compared to state and national medians, and rental costs are moderate. Madison Avenue is located in a neighborhood of downtown Toledo, a city in active revitalization with growing downtown housing stock and walkable entertainment and cultural anchors like the Glass City Riverwalk, museums, and galleries.
This is a small, arts-focused charter school with low test proficiency but a strong identity around character and creativity. It is a good fit for families who prioritize those values and are comfortable with modest academic proficiency, or who believe their child needs a smaller, arts-centered environment. Parents concerned about standardized achievement should look elsewhere.
See more original research from School Decision →