The top reported proficiency rate is 93% in Science. The lowest is 89% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Kilgour School
Kilgour School is a small elementary school serving kindergarten through sixth grade in Cincinnati, with an enrollment of roughly mid-size for that grade span. The school sits in a zip code where housing values have risen modestly year-on-year, and rental costs are climbing at a faster pace. Cincinnati itself is a city anchored by dense downtown and historic neighborhoods like Over-the-Rhine, with major employment in consumer products, healthcare, aerospace, and finance. The region has been adding residents through both regional moves and new apartment construction, concentrated downtown and in faster-growing suburban corridors.
Kilgour's academic results stand out as a strength. In the most recent state testing window, proficiency rates across the school were high: in math, the proficiency rate was above the starting point for strong elementary performance; in English language arts, proficiency was likewise robust; and in science, the rate was very strong. The school tested at full participation. These results place Kilgour well above the median among the county's districts in overall proficiency. State assessment data for earlier grades (kindergarten through second grade) is not available because Ohio does not test those grades, so parents do not have a standardized snapshot of early literacy or numeracy growth at this school. The one older data point available, from social studies in 2016-17, also showed high proficiency.
The school's enrollment reflects Cincinnati's actual demography. A large majority of the school identifies as white. A meaningful share identifies as Black or multiracial. Asian and Hispanic enrollment are smaller. Roughly one-fifth of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, suggesting a mixed-income enrollment with lower poverty concentration than some urban schools. The special populations data, including students with individualized education plans and English learners, was not available in the data provided, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about support services, class structure, and how the school staffs interventions.
Cincinnati Public Schools recently voted to renew a decade-long operating levy in November 2025, which locks in stable funding for preschool expansion and K-12 operations including college and career programs and student technology. That said, the district faced a significant budget gap heading into the 2025-26 school year and approved substantial cost reductions in June 2025, including elimination of more than a hundred classroom positions district-wide, cuts to administrative and support roles, changes to transportation, and reductions in school nursing and athletic trainer coverage. These decisions ripple through staffing levels and program capacity across the system. For Kilgour specifically, parent communication about how these changes affect classroom size, specialist access, or support services would clarify what the school looks like operationally under the new structure.
The district has also implemented a new science-of-reading curriculum approach at K-3, using Wit & Wisdom for English language arts and Wilson's Fundations for foundational skills, with trained teachers across the district in structured literacy and dyslexia support. This shift reflects a statewide push, and early district data showed third-grade reading proficiency rising meaningfully from 2022-23 to 2023-24. Kilgour, as a K-6 school, is part of that curriculum adoption.
The school's grade band does not produce a graduation rate, which would only appear at schools serving high school grades. Attendance and chronic-absenteeism data were not available. The school is not a charter, not a magnet, and serves as a regular public neighborhood school. Parents seeking more detail about class sizes, specialty programs within the elementary grades, after-school offerings, or the composition of the teaching staff should reach out to the school or the Cincinnati Public Schools office directly.
See more original research from School Decision →