The top reported proficiency rate is 37% in English language arts. The lowest is 7% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Rothenberg Preparatory Academy
Rothenberg Preparatory Academy is a small elementary school serving pre-kindergarten through sixth grade in Cincinnati, located on East Clifton Avenue in the urban core. The school enrolls about three hundred students across eight grade levels, with a student body that is predominantly Black, reflecting the city's racial and ethnic composition. Racial and ethnic data show the student population as substantially Black, with smaller numbers of multiracial, white, Hispanic, and Asian students. No data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility or English learner enrollment were available, so a parent may want to look into that directly with the school.
The school's academic performance, as measured by Ohio's State Tests in mathematics, English language arts, and science, is well below state proficiency standards across the board. In English language arts, about one-third of tested students scored at proficiency; in math, about one in seven; in science, about one in eight. These results are notably low. When positioned against other districts in Hamilton County, Rothenberg's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. A parent should view these results as a serious concern and may want to understand what specific interventions the school has in place and what trajectory the school is following.
Cincinnati Public Schools, the district that operates Rothenberg, has implemented district-wide shifts in reading instruction that reflect the Science of Reading approach, with all K-3 teachers trained in structured literacy and dyslexia support. The district adopted Wit & Wisdom for K-6 English language arts paired with Wilson's Fundations for foundational skills in the early grades, a comprehensive approach that has shown gains at the third-grade level district-wide. Rothenberg, as a school within this system, benefits from that curricular structure, though the school's own proficiency numbers suggest the approach is not yet translating into strong results at this location.
The district faced significant budget pressures heading into the 2025-26 school year, including elimination of classroom positions and changes to support services. In November 2025, voters renewed the district's operating levy, which stabilizes preschool expansion funding and core K-12 operations for the next decade without raising property taxes, providing some budget predictability going forward. That said, a parent considering Rothenberg should be aware that the district has undergone staffing reductions that may affect classroom capacity and support services.
Rothenberg sits in downtown Cincinnati, a dense urban neighborhood adjacent to Over-the-Rhine. The area is walkable with active street life and bus and streetcar transit. Housing in the zip code is moderately priced relative to national benchmarks, and rental housing is available, though home values have declined slightly in the past year. The neighborhood anchors civic life through downtown parks, the riverfront entertainment district, and proximity to major employers and cultural institutions.
This school is best suited for families seeking a neighborhood public school option in an urban setting who are prepared to engage closely with its academic challenges and to understand its current trajectory. The low proficiency results warrant a direct conversation with the school leadership about specific interventions, staffing stability, and what improvement initiatives are underway.
See more original research from School Decision →