The top reported proficiency rate is 35% in Social studies. The lowest is 29% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Charles a Mooney School
Charles A Mooney School is a public elementary and middle school serving early childhood through eighth grade in the Montclair neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio. The school sits within the Cleveland Metropolitan School District, which in December 2025 approved a significant consolidation plan that will reshape the district's footprint and reassign students across buildings by the 2026-27 school year. For families considering this school, understanding both the school's current academic standing and the district transition ahead matters equally.
The school enrolls a small to mid-sized student body distributed across ten grades, from pre-K through eighth. The student population is diverse: roughly equal shares of white, Black, and Hispanic students, with a smaller number of students identifying as multiracial. The school's racial and ethnic makeup is fairly balanced, which is notable in a district that remains segregated in many of its buildings. The free-and-reduced-price lunch participation data was not available, which limits a full picture of economic conditions at the school.
On state testing in Ohio's State Tests, Charles A Mooney's results show proficiency below the countywide midpoint. In grades three through eight, the school's overall proficiency in English language arts and math both sit in the bottom quartile among the county's districts. Across the three major tested subjects, proficiency rates fall below one-third of students. In English language arts and math combined, this reflects real academic challenge that a parent should explore directly with the school when considering placement. Science proficiency also measured below one-third. The most recent data from social studies, which comes from 2016-17 and does not reflect current performance, showed proficiency in the mid-40s for fourth grade and mid-20s for sixth grade, and that older snapshot is less relevant now. State testing participation rates are strong, above 98 percent, which means the reported results are reliable reflections of how students performed.
The school's demographic makeup—a mix of white, Black, and Hispanic students in roughly even thirds—creates a more integrated peer environment than many Cleveland schools. The grade span from pre-K through eighth is typical for elementary and middle schools in the district, though it means families will eventually need to transition to a high school outside the building.
The Cleveland housing market in which Montclair sits shows modest home values with rental costs that are affordable relative to national benchmarks. The zip code containing the school shows median home values in the low-to-mid range for the region and median rents somewhat below state averages, though like all of Cleveland it sits below national benchmarks. The county's real estate market has seen modest activity and steady supply in recent months. For families prioritizing affordability or neighborhood character, this part of Cleveland remains accessible.
The district itself is navigating substantial change. The new operating levy passed by voters in late 2024 means homeowners in the district will see property tax increases that last several years. More immediately, the consolidation plan will change which school many students attend and bus routes across the district by the 2026-27 school year. Parents should seek clarity from the district about whether Mooney is slated for closure, merger, or continuation under the new plan, since that will determine the school's future enrollment and stability.
The school made the district-wide shift to a cellphone-free environment for students and rolled out PowerSchool grade book access for parents, changes that affect classroom daily life and parent communication. These pedagogy moves represent a shift in how the school manages student attention and parent engagement.
For families, Charles A Mooney offers a racially integrated, K-8 setting in an affordable neighborhood within a district undergoing significant restructuring. The academic proficiency data points to real learning gaps that warrant direct conversation with school leadership about how they are being addressed. The uncertainty around the consolidation plan is a genuine practical question to clarify before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →