The top reported proficiency rate is 24% in English language arts. The lowest is 14% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Marion C Seltzer Elementary School
Marion C Seltzer Elementary School is a public school serving prekindergarten through eighth grade in Cleveland's West Side near the intersection of West 98th Street and other commercial corridors. It enrolls a student body that is substantially Black and Hispanic, with smaller shares of white, Asian and multiracial students. The school is moderately sized for its grade band, with just under four hundred students spread across ten grades from pre-K through middle school.
The school's academic performance is below the proficiency benchmarks within Cuyahoga County. On Ohio's state assessments in grades three through eight, proficiency rates in the most recent school year were low across all tested subjects. In English language arts, roughly one in four students achieved proficiency or above. In math, approximately one in five students met the standard. Science proficiency was the lowest, at around one in six students. These results place the school in the bottom quartile among the county's 31 elementary schools reporting on Ohio's assessment. Participation rates across all three subjects were very high, so these results reflect actual student performance rather than testing gaps. The school's academic profile suggests that most students are working substantially below grade-level expectations in core subjects.
The school sits in a Cleveland neighborhood where housing values have declined modestly over the past year, though inventory in the broader county market remains stable and active. Median home values in the 44102 zip code are moderate compared to the state and national benchmarks. Rental costs are relatively affordable on a percentage-of-income basis compared to ownership, and monthly rental rates have risen at a pace that tracks the broader cost-of-living trend.
Cleveland itself is a mixed-use city with a downtown business and cultural core, distinct neighborhoods each with their own commercial and civic anchors, and a shifting economy built increasingly on healthcare, education and services rather than manufacturing. The city has posted small population gains in recent years, with growth concentrated in downtown, University Circle and a few walkable inner neighborhoods. Most of the region's new housing construction is occurring in exurban areas. The broader Cuyahoga County housing market shows moderate inventory, and median days on market are relatively short.
Marion C Seltzer is part of the Cleveland Municipal School District, a historically large urban district that faced significant structural changes. In December 2025 the board approved a consolidation plan that will reduce the district from 88 to 59 schools by the 2026-27 school year, closing 18 buildings and merging 39 schools. This means the school's operational footprint and the transportation and peer composition for families using it may change. Additionally, voters approved a substantial new operating levy and bond extension (Issue 49) in November 2024, adding meaningful annual property tax costs for homeowners in the district. The district is also cellphone-free for all students and rolled out PowerSchool for ongoing parent access to grades.
Data on the school's special education enrollment, English learner populations, free and reduced price lunch eligibility, chronic absenteeism, discipline, staffing, and course access was not available, so a reader may want to contact the school directly to understand student support services, staff stability and the breadth of program offerings. State testing data older than the current year was not available for trend analysis. A parent considering this school should factor in the documented low proficiency rates in core subjects, the district-wide consolidation underway that may alter the school's future, and the new tax obligations attached to living in the district.
See more original research from School Decision →