The top reported proficiency rate is 38% in Social studies. The lowest is 14% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Buckeye Middle School
Buckeye Middle School is a public middle school serving grades six through eight in Columbus, located on Parsons Avenue on the south side. The school's enrollment is modest for a middle school, distributed fairly evenly across the three grades. The student body is racially diverse, with roughly equal shares of Black and white students, and smaller shares of Hispanic, multiracial, and Asian students.
The school's academic performance, measured by state proficiency testing, is substantially below grade. In the most recent testing year, the proficiency rate in math was notably low, with only a small fraction of students meeting state standards. English language arts proficiency was similarly low, and science proficiency, though slightly higher, remained well below the state expectation. State test data for social studies comes from an earlier year and is not recent enough to show current performance. On the proficiency index that spans all tested subjects and grades, Buckeye Middle School falls in the bottom quartile relative to other schools in Franklin County, a significant gap from the median school in the county.
This is a challenging academic environment. Parents considering Buckeye should understand that students here are performing substantially below state benchmarks across core subjects. The school does have relatively high participation rates on state tests, meaning absences are not driving the low results; the low proficiency reflects actual performance on assessed skills. A parent may want to look into further detail with the school about what academic supports and interventions are in place, what instructional approaches are being used, and whether the school has plans to address the proficiency gap.
The broader Columbus market context matters for families considering this school. Columbus is one of the fastest-growing large cities in the United States, with steady in-migration and an expanding job base centered on education, healthcare, state government, finance, and technology. Housing values in the school's zip code are moderate relative to the state and well below the national average, and rents are similarly modest. The area is developing, but growth has been concentrated in other submarkets; this part of south Columbus is not experiencing the construction boom visible in parts of Delaware County or Upper Arlington.
A significant consideration: in December 2024, the Columbus City Schools board voted to close Buckeye Middle School, with implementation beginning at the end of the 2025-26 school year. This means families now attending the school, or considering enrollment, should expect the school to consolidate and students to be assigned elsewhere. Families should confirm current enrollment plans and where their children would be reassigned before making any decisions about joining the school. Beyond school closures, the district faces state funding cuts and has already eliminated transportation for K-8 students attending schools other than their neighborhood or lottery schools, a change that affects how families access schools across the district.
See more original research from School Decision →