The top reported proficiency rate is 70% in Social studies. The lowest is 14% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Maize Road Elementary School
Maize Road Elementary serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in a central Columbus location and enrolls a modest population, with students distributed across all grade levels from pre-K through fifth. The student body is diverse: the school's enrollment reflects a predominantly Black student population alongside substantial Asian, Hispanic, and White populations, with a notably smaller group of students identifying as two or more races. Free-and-reduced-price lunch counts and English learner enrollment data were not available, which limits a full economic and language-access picture of the school.
State testing data shows academic proficiency well below the typical range. In the most recent results available, math and English language arts proficiency both stood at roughly one-third of students meeting state standards. Science proficiency was considerably lower, with only a small percentage of tested students meeting the standard. These results place the school in the bottom quartile when compared to elementary schools across Franklin County. One limitation: the school serves grades pre-K through five, but Ohio tests grades three through five and higher, so the breadth of proficiency data captures only the upper grades. Science testing included a very small tested group, reflecting the limited scope of science assessment at the elementary level. Older social studies data from 2016-17 showed mixed results across different grades. The school has one year of proficiency trend data, which is insufficient to show whether performance is rising, falling, or stable.
Columbus is in the midst of rapid residential and economic growth. The housing market in the school's zip code is moderately priced relative to national benchmarks and somewhat below the Ohio state average. Rents are correspondingly moderate. The region is adding residents at roughly double the national growth rate, driven by major employer expansion and corporate investment, which affects housing demand and family demographics across the city. Columbus City Schools recently approved a continuing property tax levy in 2023 to fund operating expenses and capital improvements, which has become a permanent feature of the district's funding and affects family budgets. The district is also undergoing significant consolidation, having voted to close multiple schools in December 2024 and again in December 2025, with more closures and boundary redraws affecting families across the system. Maize Road was not named among the schools slated for closure, though the district's ongoing realignment means families should verify boundary assignments and transportation policies with the school directly, as these have changed.
A parent or resident considering Maize Road should recognize the school's academic results as a meaningful concern. The proficiency levels are low, and science instruction appears thin. The school's student body composition reflects Columbus's diversity and residential patterns, which some families value and others seek to navigate carefully. The broader context of Columbus City Schools consolidation, transportation cuts (effective for K-8 students attending schools other than their neighborhood or lottery-assigned school), and ongoing budget pressures is important background for any family planning to stay in the district long-term. For families prioritizing proven academic strength or robust course breadth, a parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand what supports exist for students working below standard and what the school's plan is for improvement.
See more original research from School Decision →