The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Math. The lowest is 25% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on South Mifflin Stem Academy (k-6)
South Mifflin STEM Academy serves students from pre-K through sixth grade in Columbus, a city experiencing robust growth anchored by major employers from healthcare and finance to education and technology. The school is a regular public school within Columbus City Schools District, a mid-sized urban district that has made strategic shifts in recent years, notably moving all elementary teachers to science-of-reading instruction starting in 2021, now aligned with state mandate. The district approved a property tax levy in 2023 to expand pre-K and sustain programs, a permanent cost for families in the area. More recently, significant budget pressures have led the district to close multiple schools and eliminate transportation for most K-8 students attending non-neighborhood schools, changes that reshape school access and planning across the district.
The student body at South Mifflin is predominantly Black, with smaller shares of students identifying as Hispanic, multiracial, or white. Data on students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch and on special populations like English learners and students with IEPs was not available. The school enrolls a small population overall for its grade band, with numbers relatively stable across grades.
In academic performance, the school's recent state test results show uneven standing. In math, student proficiency sits in the middle range relative to other districts in Franklin County. English language arts proficiency is lower, trailing the county median noticeably. Science proficiency is notably weaker, placing the school in the bottom quartile among county districts. When looking across all tested subjects and grades together, South Mifflin's overall proficiency index sits in the bottom quartile of Franklin County schools. The science result is particularly sparse, with only a small group of students tested, so a parent may want to look into further whether science instruction is still developing or whether testing capacity is limited at the school's grade levels. Social studies data available from an earlier year showed sharp variability by grade, with notably low performance in sixth grade; current data on this subject is not available.
The school's location in the Middlehurst Drive area of Columbus places it in a neighborhood characterized by the broader city's mixed texture. Columbus itself is the state capital and largest city, with historic walkable neighborhoods near downtown (German Village, Short North, Olde Towne East) that contrast with car-oriented suburban-style development across much of the metro. The city is one of the fastest-growing major metros in the U.S., driven by a diversified employer base spanning healthcare, finance, retail, and logistics, plus Intel's planned semiconductor campus bringing new jobs to the region. Housing in the school's zip code is relatively affordable against national benchmarks, with monthly rent and mortgage costs both below the national median. The area has experienced steady modest appreciation in home values.
For families considering this school, the principal questions are the weak overall proficiency levels, particularly in reading and science, and the recent district-wide belt-tightening that eliminated busing for most K-8 students outside their neighborhood school, which affects access and transportation planning. The school's position within a high-growth city with strong employment diversity may appeal to families planning longer-term residence, though current academic performance merits conversation with the school about improvement initiatives and instructional supports, especially given the district's shift to science-of-reading methods and whether that work is yet showing results.
See more original research from School Decision →