The top reported proficiency rate is 86% in Social studies. The lowest is 77% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Ervin Carlisle Elementary School
Ervin Carlisle Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Delaware, Ohio, a fast-growing county seat about a half hour north of Columbus. The school sits in a community undergoing substantial residential expansion, with multiple large housing developments reshaping the area. The school itself is a regular public elementary school with an enrollment across its grade band typical for the area.
On state assessments, the school's performance is solid. In English language arts, students reached proficiency at a rate notably higher than the county median among districts in Delaware County, placing the school in the top quartile for overall proficiency across tested subjects. Science proficiency was also strong. Math proficiency was moderate, somewhat below the ELA level but still within range. The proficiency index—a mean of reported results across subjects—positioned the school above the county midpoint. Test participation was nearly complete across all assessed grades, indicating stable engagement with the state assessment system.
The school's enrollment is distributed fairly evenly across grades, with slightly fewer students in fourth grade than in the other grades. Just over a quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, suggesting a middle-class student population with some economic diversity. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller populations of students identifying as multiracial, Hispanic, Black, Asian, and American Indian or Alaska Native. The school does not report counts or rates for students with individualized education programs or English learners, which is typical for early-elementary schools; these data are not missing from the school's operations but rather not separately reported at the elementary level by the state.
The surrounding community has a historic downtown anchored by locally headquartered Greif Inc. and the adjacent Ohio Wesleyan University campus, with civic institutions and a recognized main street district. The area supports walkable neighborhoods and has active parks including Mingo Park on the Olentangy River. Housing values and rents have risen modestly in the past year, and the market sits above national benchmarks on a price-to-income basis, reflecting both local demand and the broader regional growth. For families considering a move, the Delaware City Schools district in November 2025 passed a new continuing property tax improvement levy generating annual revenue for building maintenance, buses, technology, and materials—a cost families would factor into overall housing affordability when relocating.
At the classroom level, the district beginning in the 2023-24 school year shifted K-3 reading instruction to a Science of Reading and Structured Literacy approach, altering how early readers are taught and what reading materials and homework come home. This pedagogy change touches the daily practice of young students and families new to the school.
The school participates in Ohio's state testing system and reports its results directly. No federal Title I designation status is listed, and the school does not operate as a charter or magnet school. Additional details on staffing, discipline policies, course access, attendance rates, or specialized programs were not available in the data provided, so families interested in those specifics may want to reach out to the school directly.
See more original research from School Decision →