The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Social studies. The lowest is 0% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Elmwood Elementary School
Elmwood Elementary serves grades two through five in Garfield Heights, an urban suburb south of Cleveland rooted in industrial and working-class neighborhoods with a long history of Polish, Slovene, German, Italian, Irish, and African-American settlement. The school sits on Turney Road in a city whose civic anchors—the library, recreation center, city hall, and high school—cluster along that same corridor.
The enrollment is small, concentrated heavily in grades two and three, with the full student body predominantly Black. Racial composition is relatively diverse within the school's immediate peer group, with students who are multiracial and small numbers of Hispanic and white students, though the student population skews toward one racial group. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch status and on students receiving special education services or English learner support were not available, so a parent would want to ask the school directly about the economic and linguistic makeup of the student body and what support services are available.
Academically, Elmwood's recent state test results show weaker proficiency in both English language arts and mathematics. The school sits in the bottom quartile of schools in Cuyahoga County on an overall proficiency measure. Math and ELA proficiency rates are each below four in ten, and state science testing data from the most recent year available was limited to a very small number of test-takers, making that result difficult to interpret. The school participates fully in state testing, so the low results are not a testing-access issue.
The Garfield Heights City Schools district has faced repeated setbacks on school funding. Voters rejected a major bond for facility improvements in 2023, defeated a routine renewal levy in March 2024 (a striking outcome for a no-new-taxes renewal), and rejected another renewal attempt in May 2025, the only renewal that failed among school districts in the region that year. These defeats mean no new middle school or athletic facilities are being built, and operating revenue for classroom resources and technology remains under pressure. A recent countywide property reappraisal increased property valuations substantially, making any new school millage more costly for Garfield Heights homeowners and complicating the path to stable funding.
For families considering Elmwood, the combination of low proficiency, resource constraints from failed levies, and limited visible data on specialized services creates a complex picture. Parents may want to visit the school, ask about tutoring and intervention programs, connect with current families, and explore what the district is doing to address academic performance given the funding pressure. The school's size and elementary focus make it an intimate setting, but the academic foundation would be a key question for any family weighing options.
See more original research from School Decision →