The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in English language arts. The lowest is 0% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on William Foster Elementary School
William Foster Elementary School serves pre-kindergarten through third grade in Garfield Heights, a Cleveland suburb with a mixed residential, commercial, and industrial base rooted in working- and middle-class communities. The school enrolls students from a neighborhood where a substantial majority are Black, with smaller shares of white and multiracial students and very few Asian or Hispanic students.
The school's test performance data carries important caveats. In the most recent tested grade for which data is available, grade three in 2024, the tested cohort was extremely small—just one student in math and one in language arts. That single student performed at proficiency in English language arts but did not meet proficiency in math. The science result, from 2023 when the school tested students in grade five, showed proficiency at less than half of students tested. A 2017 social studies result from grade four showed solid performance, though that result is now nearly a decade old. Taken together, these results paint an incomplete picture. The school's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint among the district's peers in Cuyahoga County, a positioning that parents may want to explore further with the school directly to understand current classroom conditions and support systems.
The enrollment pattern reflects an unusual structure. The school has a strong early-grades footprint, with substantial enrollment in pre-kindergarten and kindergarten but very few students in grades two and three. This may reflect either recent demographic shifts in the catchment area, a transition to a different grade configuration, or enrollment movement to other schools as students advance. Understanding what drives this pattern is worth asking the school about, as it can signal staffing stability and the continuity of learning relationships.
Garfield Heights itself is experiencing both opportunity and financial stress. The city is pursuing major development including the Transportation Boulevard corridor extension and a large county services campus. However, the school district faces significant headwinds. Operating levies have failed repeatedly in recent elections, including a routine renewal that had passed for decades until a 2024 defeat, and another renewal failure in May 2025. District leaders have warned that these failures threaten classroom resources, technology funding, and staffing. Simultaneously, a 2024 property reappraisal in Cuyahoga County raised property valuations substantially, increasing the tax burden on homeowners of any future school millage. Families should be aware that budget uncertainty is currently shaping district operations and may affect classroom conditions and programming.
Housing values in the area remain accessible. A family buying in the school's zip code would find median home values and rental prices considerably below state and national benchmarks, though recent data shows modest year-over-year appreciation. The affordability profile is favorable for working families, though rents have risen meaningfully over the past year.
William Foster is structured as a traditional public elementary school with no charter or magnet designation. The early-grades focus, small upper-grade cohorts, and performance data below district peers suggest this is a school where parents should seek direct conversation with administration about current instructional approaches, class sizes, staffing continuity, and the school's trajectory. The combination of testing results in a very small tested sample, enrollment shape questions, and district-level budget pressures makes this a school where understanding the full picture requires engagement beyond the available data.
See more original research from School Decision →