The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in Social studies. The lowest is 0% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Independence Elementary School
Independence Elementary School serves prekindergarten through fourth grade in Lima, Ohio's Allen County. The school enrolls a modest population across its grade band, with a racially and ethnically mixed student body: roughly two-fifths white, a notable share Black, and smaller portions Hispanic, multiracial, and Asian. The free-or-reduced-price-lunch count was not available in the data, so family economic circumstances are unclear from this source.
State testing results in reading and mathematics reveal proficiency rates well below what the school aims for. In the most recent year, roughly a third of students tested met or exceeded proficiency in math, while just over a quarter did so in reading. Averaged across tested subjects, Independence scores in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Allen County. The school's performance sits squarely in a range where targeted intervention and instructional focus typically matter most. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, including what specific supports and reading or math acceleration strategies are in place for students who are not yet proficient.
The district itself is navigating real constraints. A permanent improvement and operating levy has been in place since 2021 and is up for renewal on the November 2026 ballot; district leaders have stated plainly that the renewal, while needed, will not eliminate the deficit, meaning budget pressures will remain a factor in program offerings and staffing. At the same time, Lima City Schools has committed to a significant instructional shift, adopting Core Knowledge Language Arts (CKLA), a thematic, knowledge-building reading curriculum for kindergarten through eighth grade that changes how teachers plan and teach. The district is emphasizing implementation fidelity over frequent program switches, meaning the curriculum work is intended to settle in and show results over time rather than be replaced year after year.
Lima itself is an Allen County seat and former industrial hub in northwest Ohio experiencing active downtown and housing revitalization. The city has invested in pedestrian infrastructure, parks, and community amenities, including a new aquatic park that opened in 2025. Major employers include two hospitals, manufacturing plants (including the Ford Lima Engine Plant and General Dynamics Joint Systems Manufacturing), and Dana Corporation. Housing values are below both state and national benchmarks, making the area more affordable; rental costs are similarly modest relative to national figures.
Independence Elementary's neighborhood sits within this context of a mid-sized Rust Belt city with ongoing civic investment but also the economic realities of older infrastructure and legacy population shifts. Families choosing this school should expect an elementary program focused on foundational reading and math, situated in a district managing real budget constraints while committing to new pedagogical direction. The school's proficiency gaps point to a setting where strong classroom instruction, family engagement, and targeted support will be critical factors in whether a child thrives.
See more original research from School Decision →