The top reported proficiency rate is 16% in English language arts. The lowest is 9% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Sherman Elementary School
Sherman Elementary School serves children from Pre-K through second grade in Mansfield, Ohio. The school enrolls a diverse group of students: the student body is split roughly between white students and Black students, with smaller shares of students identifying as two or more races, Hispanic, or Native American. Sherman sits in a city that was once a manufacturing hub and now blends services, healthcare, and education with remaining industrial presence. Housing in the area is substantially cheaper than the state and national averages, making it accessible to families on modest incomes.
The school is located at an address on Springmill Street in a neighborhood setting. It is a regular public elementary school, not a charter or magnet program. Across its four grades, Sherman serves a student population of roughly five hundred, with Pre-K being the largest grade cohort and second grade the next largest.
Academic performance at Sherman measured by state testing is a weak spot. Third graders tested in 2021-22 showed proficiency rates that were very low: roughly one in twelve met proficiency in math, and roughly one in six met proficiency in English language arts. This places Sherman well below the median performance level for elementary schools in Richland County. The data available does not include results for Pre-K, kindergarten, or first grade, as Ohio does not test those grades. More recent state test data was not available, so it is unclear whether performance has shifted since that 2021-22 school year. A parent may want to ask the school directly about current performance trends and what steps the school has taken in response.
The wider Mansfield City School District has made a concrete shift toward structured-literacy approaches to reading instruction, adopting the Fundations curriculum for K-3 students and adding dyslexia screening and teacher training. Sherman would be affected by this adoption. The district also consolidated its footprint by closing two school buildings between 2022 and 2024, redrawing attendance areas. Sherman is now designated as the Pre-K through 2 attendance-area school for the district; families in its attendance zone will enroll their children there unless they apply to one of the district's magnet programs (Spanish Immersion, Springmill STEM, or Tyger Digital Academy).
The district faces budget constraints following a November 2024 referendum failure; voters rejected a combined operating tax and property-tax levy by a significant margin. Prior to that, the district had closed buildings, ended a virtual academy, and implemented departmentwide budget cuts. A stable five-year emergency levy approved in 2022 provides baseline operating funding, but the failed referendum leaves the district working within tighter resources than it sought. This context may affect staffing, program breadth, and the district's ability to invest in new initiatives.
Mansfield itself is in the early stages of downtown revitalization, with a major Main Street Corridor Improvement underway through mid-2026 aimed at rebuilding walkability and civic gathering spaces. The city captured population growth in 2023, unusual among Ohio cities, and is positioning to benefit from spillover from a major semiconductor plant an hour to the south. Affordable housing development is expanding, though a recent housing needs assessment noted that the supply of affordable houses has decreased since an earlier period. The neighborhood texture is older, blue-collar, with a mix of restored historic buildings downtown and working-class residential areas surrounding the core.
Enrollment data for special populations, free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility, and detailed staffing information were not available, so a parent seeking detail on those dimensions should contact the school or district directly.
See more original research from School Decision →