The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Rutherford B. Hayes Elementary School
Rutherford B. Hayes Elementary School serves an early-elementary and pre-K student body spanning grades PK through 5 in Marion, a small city with a manufacturing-anchored economy in north-central Ohio. The school sits within Marion City Schools, a district that has recently undergone significant programming shifts.
The school's student composition reflects Marion's broader population: a majority white enrollment, with smaller groups identifying as multiracial, Hispanic, and Black. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data was not available in the reporting. Special education and English learner counts were similarly not reported.
On Ohio's State Tests, the school's performance is mixed. In English language arts, roughly half of tested students in grades 3-5 achieved proficiency or above. Math proficiency was notably lower, with fewer than two in five students at proficiency level. Science showed performance between those two subjects. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile when compared to other districts in Marion County. Reading achievement is the school's stronger area; mathematics appears to be the area most in need of instructional focus. Given that the school teaches only early grades, high school outcomes and graduation rates do not apply.
Marion City Schools has launched several district-wide initiatives that touch all schools, including a new Lincoln Academy program for at-risk students, a substantial investment in K-12 literacy instruction, and adoption of a social-emotional learning curriculum called Character Strong paired with expanded mental health partnerships. These changes signal an intentional reframing of how the district approaches struggling learners and student wellness. The district also completed a consolidation and cost-restructuring effort that reallocated funding toward classrooms and facilities.
The school itself is located in Marion's residential core, a mixed-use small city undergoing quiet redevelopment. Downtown has seen historic building conversions into housing and businesses, and newer suburban subdivisions are appearing on the city's edges. Housing values have appreciated modestly year-over-year, and the market remains affordable compared to state and national benchmarks. Marion's economy is anchored by Whirlpool's massive dryer manufacturing facility and other industrial employers, alongside institutional anchors like OhioHealth Marion General Hospital and Marion Technical College. Bus transit is available through Marion Area Transit, and pedestrian infrastructure downtown is improving through a planned streetscape project.
A parent considering this school should weigh the school's mathematics achievement against the district's recent literacy and at-risk student initiatives, understand that early-elementary proficiency translates differently than middle or high school results, and recognize that the school operates within a district in a period of programmatic transition.
See more original research from School Decision →