The top reported proficiency rate is 50% in Social studies. The lowest is 22% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on James A. Garfield Elementary School
James A. Garfield Elementary School serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Marion, Ohio, a small industrial city with a manufacturing heritage. The school enrolls a small student body across its early grade bands, with enrollment relatively balanced across grades and pre-K through fifth grade all represented on campus.
The student composition is predominantly white, with smaller populations of multiracial, Hispanic, and Black students. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and special education or English learner populations were not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about the economic and linguistic diversity of the population.
On state testing, Garfield's performance across grades three through five places it in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Marion County. In English language arts, about two in five students in the tested grades meet proficiency standards. Mathematics proficiency runs somewhat lower, at just over one in three students. Science proficiency is notably lower, with about one in five students proficient. Participation in state testing is high, suggesting the figures are reliable. The data provided does not allow a trend comparison, so it is unclear whether these results represent an improving, stable, or declining trajectory; a parent may want to ask the district about prior years' performance and any initiatives underway to address these levels.
Marion itself is a mixed-use city undergoing modest revitalization. Downtown is walkable and historic, with recent National Register additions and conversion of buildings to lofts and offices. Manufacturing remains the largest employer, anchored by a major Whirlpool facility and Nucor Steel. Home values in the area have appreciated modestly year over year and remain affordable compared to state and national benchmarks. The city is investing in trails, pedestrian infrastructure, and streetscape improvements slated to begin in the near term. Schools sit on separated campuses rather than downtown, reflecting the city's car-oriented design.
The Marion City School District has made recent programmatic investments that touch every school in the system. The district launched Lincoln Academy to support at-risk and off-track students, committed substantial resources to K-12 literacy instruction, and rolled out new curriculum maps for instructional alignment across grades. Character Strong, a social-emotional learning curriculum, is now district-wide, supported by expanded mental health partnerships. A right-sizing initiative consolidated the district's physical footprint and redirected savings back into classrooms and facilities.
For families considering Garfield, the school offers a small, neighborhood elementary environment in an affordably-priced community with active civic investment and civic institutions. Current test results in math, ELA, and science sit below the county median, which a parent may want to explore further with the school in the context of the recent literacy and alignment initiatives underway across the district.
See more original research from School Decision →