The top reported proficiency rate is 96% in Social studies. The lowest is 84% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Sidney Fenn Elementary School
Sidney Fenn Elementary is a mid-sized school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Medina, a small county-seat city south of Cleveland that has been growing steadily. The school sits within Medina City Schools, a district that has navigated significant financial strain and operational restructuring in recent years.
The district's path to current stability has been rocky. After two levy failures in 2024, voters narrowly approved an operating levy in November of that year—the district's first new operating money since the early 2010s. That financial crisis prompted substantial cuts across the district and a consolidation of elementary schools. Sidney Fenn emerged as one of the schools kept open; two of the district's seven elementaries were closed, with one converted to preschool and another to district offices. This reorganization redrew attendance boundaries district-wide, a change that has since settled into a new equilibrium.
Sidney Fenn's academic performance is solid. In math proficiency among grades three through five, students at the school outperformed the median of districts across Medina County, placing in the top quartile when proficiency across all tested subjects and grades is considered together. English language arts proficiency and science proficiency both sit in that same range, with four in five students or better meeting proficiency standards in each area. These results reflect a school where instruction is working for the majority of the student body.
The school enrolls roughly four hundred students, with roughly equal cohorts across the six grades. About three in ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student population is predominantly white, with smaller percentages of students identifying as multiracial, Hispanic, Asian, or Black. Data on students with individual education plans or English learners was not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about the scope of those services.
The Medina housing market shows modest strength. Home values in the area have grown slightly year-over-year, and rental rates have climbed as well. The cost of homeownership sits above the national benchmark, making the property-tax bite from the new levy a real consideration for families moving into the district. Rents, by comparison, have tracked lower relative to mortgage costs, which may appeal to some households.
Medina itself is actively developing, with multiple new residential subdivisions on the north side and surrounding townships under construction. The downtown sits around a restored historic square with civic anchors—the courthouse, the county library, local shops and restaurants—making it a genuinely walkable core. Beyond the square, commercial life is auto-oriented along Route 42. The area's major employers span healthcare, manufacturing, and retail, providing a stable if not dramatic employment base.
Sidney Fenn, as a regular public elementary school within a district that has stabilized after crisis, offers a mainstream academic program in a community that is neither booming nor declining. A parent choosing this school would be selecting a school in the solid middle of its peer group, without the kind of specialized programming or standout differentiation that shapes some schools' character.
See more original research from School Decision →