The top reported proficiency rate is 62% in Social studies. The lowest is 35% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Central Academy Nongraded Elementary School
Central Academy Nongraded Elementary School serves kindergarten through sixth grade in Middletown, a mid-sized city in Butler County positioned between Cincinnati and Dayton. The school sits in a community marked by revitalization efforts, with downtown anchored by the restored Sorg Opera House and walkable Main Street, while residential neighborhoods and new townhome developments spread toward the I-75 corridor. The city's economy reflects its steel and paper heritage alongside diversified employers including Cleveland-Cliffs, Atrium Medical Center, and Kroger, with modest annual population growth.
The school's academic performance shows proficiency in core tested subjects below the midpoint among districts in Butler County. In recent state assessments, the school's proficiency rates across math, English language arts, and science placed it in the bottom quartile relative to other Butler County districts. Mathematics proficiency was below prior mathematics results, and science proficiency was notably lower still. English language arts showed marginally stronger results, though still below half of students demonstrating proficiency. A science assessment covered only a fraction of the tested student population, which may reflect the grade-band structure of this elementary school. Social studies data is older, drawn from 2016-17, and is not comparable to current performance.
The student body is racially and ethnically diverse. White students comprise a majority, with substantial representation of multiracial, Black, and Hispanic students. The school's enrollment is stable across grade bands, with roughly balanced cohorts from kindergarten through sixth grade. Free-or-reduced-price-lunch rates and counts for special education and English learners were not available in the reported data.
The school name "Nongraded" reflects a pedagogical structure that aligns students across grades rather than by single-grade cohorts, a model intended to support differentiation. However, data on how this structure affects outcomes, classroom composition, or instructional pacing was not provided.
The district is in the midst of substantial structural change. In January 2025, the Middletown City Schools approved elementary redistricting that took effect for the 2025-26 school year, reconfiguring all elementary buildings and moving sixth graders out of a dedicated sixth-grade center into neighborhood K-6 schools. Central Academy relocated to the Highview building, which had served as a sixth-grade center, while the district's Early Learning Center moved into Central Academy's former building. This was the district's first major redistricting since the mid-1990s and altered attendance boundaries across the city. Simultaneously, the district experienced significant staffing reductions as federal pandemic relief funding ended, cutting more than 40 positions including elementary counselors, literacy tutors, and classroom assistants that families had relied on. The U.S. Department of Education also rescinded funding for a district transportation and maintenance facility mid-project, creating additional budgetary pressure.
On the high school level, the district is launching a comprehensive redesign with the 2025-26 freshman class, introducing project-based learning, career pathways, and real-world campus experiences such as a student-run credit union and coffee shop. This district-wide initiative stems from the Passport to Tomorrow strategic effort.
For a family considering this school, the key questions center on how the recent redistricting and building moves have settled, what the nongraded instructional model offers relative to other nearby schools, and how classroom support staffing reductions affect daily instruction and student attention. The proficiency data suggests this school faces academic headwinds; a parent may want to look into further details with the school about curriculum, intervention programs, and the impact of recent structural shifts on teaching and learning. The diverse student body and stable enrollment suggest a neighborhood school presence in a city actively reshaping itself.
See more original research from School Decision →