The top reported proficiency rate is 43% in Social studies. The lowest is 16% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Mt. Healthy South Elementary School
Mt. Healthy South Elementary School serves students in grades one through six from a location in the Mt. Healthy area of Cincinnati. With an enrollment distributed fairly evenly across the grade levels, the school draws a student body that is predominantly Black, with smaller shares of students from Hispanic, multiracial, and white backgrounds. The school's racial composition reflects the neighborhood it serves.
On state tests in math and English language arts, student proficiency rates are low. In most recent testing, proficiency in math reached the low teen range, while English language arts performance was somewhat higher but still in the low-twenties range. Science proficiency was higher, though testing for that subject applied to a smaller number of students. When these results are placed alongside other schools tested in Hamilton County, Mt. Healthy South sits in the bottom quartile on an overall proficiency index. A parent reviewing these numbers would want to understand directly from the school what instructional approaches are in place and what supports exist for students who are not yet meeting grade-level benchmarks.
The school operates within Mt. Healthy City Schools, a district that has faced significant financial strain. The district was placed under state fiscal emergency in 2024 due to accounting errors and a projected operating deficit. This led to reductions of more than several hundred staff positions district-wide and cuts to student transportation down to the state minimum. That context is important: reduced staffing can affect class sizes and the availability of support services, and reduced busing means families may need to arrange their own transportation or live within walking distance.
There is positive news on the district's financial horizon. In May 2026, voters narrowly approved an earned income tax levy, the district's first levy passage in more than two decades, after three prior defeats. This new revenue is earmarked for staffing, classroom materials, transportation, utilities, and arts and athletics programs that had faced elimination. The tax will be felt directly in paychecks of working residents, but it creates a more stable funding path going forward. Even so, the staffing cuts and transportation reductions that occurred during the fiscal emergency represent structural changes that will persist unless and until the district rebuilds those positions.
Housing in the school's zip code area is relatively affordable compared to state and national benchmarks. Home values reflect a modest market, and rental costs are well below state medians. The area is not in a rapid-growth corridor; the broader Cincinnati region is seeing development concentrated in downtown and faster-growing suburbs. The neighborhood around Mt. Healthy South is a working residential area.
A family considering this school would be making a choice based on proximity and practicality rather than on academic strength. The school's proficiency results are weak, and that pattern sits within a district that has weathered serious financial hardship. The newly approved levy helps stabilize the district's outlook, but the effects of prior cuts to staffing and services remain real. Families should have direct conversations with the school about current staffing levels, class sizes, interventions for students below grade level, and what the school's plan is for using the new levy funding to rebuild capacity.
See more original research from School Decision →