The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Science. The lowest is 49% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Niles Middle School
Niles Middle School serves grades six through eight in the Niles City School District, a mid-sized public school in a Rust Belt community in Trumbull County that has recently stabilized after years of fiscal turmoil. The school enrollment is small, reflecting the size of Niles itself — a city of some scale in the Youngstown-Warren metro whose economy has shifted from steel and iron manufacturing to retail and light manufacturing centered on the Eastwood Mall complex.
Academically, Niles Middle performs below the midpoint for districts in Trumbull County. On the most recent state assessments, roughly half the students achieved proficiency in English language arts and math, while science proficiency ran higher. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile among county districts. State testing data was the only academic measure available; the school does not report trend data across multiple years, so it is not possible to say whether performance is moving or stable. Graduation rate and chronic absenteeism data do not apply to a middle school and were not reported.
The student body reflects the city's demographics and economic conditions. About seven in ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a high share indicating substantial economic hardship in the families served. The enrollment is predominantly white, with smaller shares of Black students, Hispanic students, and students identifying with two or more races. Data on special education enrollment and English learner enrollment were not available. The school is a regular public school, not charter or magnet, and operates within the Niles City School District.
Niles City Schools itself has undergone significant change since 2022. The district exited state fiscal emergency in January 2022 after years of fiscal watch or emergency status dating back decades, a shift that directly affects school stability, staffing, and program continuity that families weigh when choosing where to live. Voters approved a district renewal levy on the first attempt in November 2022, a departure from the district's history of failed first attempts, and the district switched to a county insurance consortium expected to improve the budget outlook. These moves have stabilized the five-year forecast. The district also launched its own preschool program in 2022-23, housed at the primary school, adding an early-childhood option for families in the district.
The broader Niles community is in the early phases of downtown revitalization. The city is implementing a public square and riverfront park project, updating zoning codes to allow denser housing around the retail corridor and the Eastwood Mall area, and moving forward with adaptive reuse of historic buildings. Housing values and rents in the zip code are modest compared to state and national benchmarks, with median home values well below both the state and U.S. average, making the area affordable for families seeking lower housing costs in a region with manufacturing and service-sector job growth.
A parent considering this school should understand that it serves a student population facing real economic strain, that academic proficiency is below the county norm, and that the school operates without the benefit of recent multi-year achievement data to show whether performance is headed in a particular direction. Families should also know that the district itself has moved out of fiscal crisis and has begun adding services such as preschool, steps that may support stability going forward. The city is actively developing downtown and housing, suggesting an intent to attract and retain residents. Whether Niles Middle is the right fit depends on a family's expectations around test performance, their tolerance for below-average county proficiency, and their interest in being part of a community undergoing managed transition and modest revitalization.
See more original research from School Decision →