The top reported proficiency rate is 26% in English language arts. The lowest is 9% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on North College Hill Middle School
North College Hill Middle School serves grades five through eight in a school of roughly mid-sized enrollment on the west side of Cincinnati. The student body is predominantly African American, with smaller shares of students identifying as multiracial, Hispanic, or white. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and special education or English learner populations were not available.
State testing results from 2024-25 show proficiency well below what parents would expect from a functioning school. In English language arts, roughly one-quarter of students scored at proficient or higher. In math, the proficiency rate fell to single digits. Science proficiency was similarly low, in the low twenties. These results place North College Hill Middle School in the bottom quartile when compared to other districts across Hamilton County. Participation rates in state testing were high, around 98 percent, so the low proficiency numbers reflect student performance rather than testing gaps.
The school is part of the North College Hill City school district, which is navigating serious fiscal strain. The district lost a major block of state funding and, following a failed tax levy in May 2026, implemented steep cuts: eighteen teacher layoffs and five educational aide cuts took effect for 2026-27, with officials warning of additional reductions. If a ballot measure planned for November also fails, the district plans to eliminate after-school programs, field trips, and extracurriculars including band, drama, and athletics. These cuts will directly affect what middle school students have access to beyond core classes.
A structural change affecting all families is the move to a four-day school week with remote or blended learning on Mondays, now a permanent fixture as of 2023-24. Students get Mondays off; the district uses that time for teacher planning and career-shadowing opportunities. This affects childcare arrangements and compresses instructional time into a shorter week.
The immediate context for enrollment decisions is one of constrained resources and uncertain program availability. State assessment data shows students at North College Hill Middle School are not meeting grade-level standards in core subjects at expected rates. The district is in active budget crisis mode, with ongoing debate over tax measures and real cuts to staffing and offerings. A parent considering this school would want to have detailed conversations with the school and district about how instruction and support are being delivered under these constraints, what extracurricular or enrichment pathways remain available, and what the trajectory might be if further cuts occur. The four-day schedule is a fixed feature that works for some families and not others.
See more original research from School Decision →