The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Math. The lowest is 49% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Heritage Hill Elementary School
Heritage Hill Elementary is a small, neighborhood school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in the Chesterdale area on Cincinnati's eastern edge. The school enrolls students from a predominantly low-income community with very high need. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch; the student body is majority Hispanic, with significant Black and smaller white and multiracial populations. The school sits within Princeton City Schools, which in May 2025 narrowly passed an emergency property-tax levy after a failed November 2024 vote had already triggered staff reductions, hiring freezes, and threatened school closures. That levy now funds ongoing operations and staffing across the district.
On state testing, Heritage Hill's results are mixed. In math, students score in the moderate range, with a meaningful share reaching proficiency. Reading and language arts performance lags behind math, with less than a majority meeting proficiency. Science proficiency is notably lower, with roughly half the typical rate in the other subjects. Because the school serves only early elementary grades, there is no graduation rate or high-school outcome data. The school sits below the midpoint of other tested schools across Hamilton County in overall proficiency when you look at average performance across all tested subjects and grades.
The Chesterdale neighborhood where Heritage Hill is located sits in a housing market with modest home values and rental rates typical for its region. The area is car-dependent rather than walkable, characteristic of Cincinnati's hillside residential zones that spread outward from the city core. The broader Cincinnati metro has seen steady in-migration and development activity, though growth is concentrated in downtown and several faster-growing suburban corridors. The riverfront, downtown's revitalized entertainment and cultural districts, and the University of Cincinnati are all accessible from this neighborhood, but not within walking distance.
What Heritage Hill offers is a traditional public elementary school rooted in its immediate community. It is small enough for students to be known by staff, and large enough to support a full set of grade levels and specialists. A parent looking at this school should understand its students are predominantly from families with limited financial resources and whose primary language may not be English; staff is working with that reality. The recent levy crisis and its ongoing resolution mean the district is managing tightly, but with the emergency levy now in place, the school's continued operation and current staffing are secured through the levy period. A parent may want to look into the details of reading support and intervention, particularly in earlier grades, given the gap between math and literacy performance, and to ask the school directly about science instruction and resources.
See more original research from School Decision →