The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Social studies. The lowest is 34% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Stiles Elementary School
Stiles Elementary School serves pre-K through fourth grade students in Columbus's near west side and sits within South-Western City Schools, a district that covers parts of Franklin County outside the city proper. The school enrolls a small to mid-sized student body, with substantial enrollment across every grade from pre-K onward and nearly a quarter of spots in pre-K and kindergarten.
The student population reflects Columbus's demographic diversity. Hispanic students make up the largest single group, followed by Black students, with smaller shares of white students and students of multiple races; Asian students are present in very small numbers. The overwhelming majority of families qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which signals concentrated economic need in the attendance area. Data on students receiving special education services or English learner support was not provided, so parents may want to ask the school directly about those programs, especially given that the broader district serves learners who speak many different languages.
State test results for grades three through four in math and ELA show proficiency rates in the low-to-mid range. In the most recent school year, the proficiency rate in math was around one-third of tested students, and in ELA it was slightly lower. Both rates place Stiles in the bottom quartile of schools across Franklin County's districts when measuring overall proficiency. The school does have one older data point, from social studies in the fourth grade, showing stronger results, but that is now several years old and is not directly comparable to current assessments. Parents evaluating this school should understand that achievement on state measures is substantially below average for the region and ask the school about reading and math support programs, intervention strategies, and how the school is addressing the gap.
Columbus itself is one of the fastest-growing large cities in the country, anchored by a diversified economy centered on state government, higher education, healthcare, finance, and corporate headquarters. The metro area is adding residents at roughly double the national rate. Housing in the 43228 zip code where Stiles sits is more affordable than the state and national median, with median home values below the Ohio benchmark and rental costs at a modest share of median household income. The neighborhood supports working and low-to-middle-income families rather than affluent ones.
At the district level, South-Western City Schools made headlines in 2025 when the board voted to join professional organizations whose stated positions include removing students with significant learning needs from general education classrooms and raising concerns about serving non-English speakers. That decision prompted sustained opposition from parents and families already navigating special education and English learner services. Families with students in those categories have publicly reported considering leaving the district. The district has also recently invested in new middle school buildings, a durable facilities upgrade. Kindergarten entry age has shifted as well, moving from September 30 to an earlier August cutoff, which affects enrollment timing for late-summer birthdays.
For families considering Stiles, the core question is whether the school's current achievement levels and the district's recent positioning on special education and language learners align with their needs and values. The school operates in a high-need, high-poverty area with below-regional achievement. If your student receives or may need special education or English learner services, the district's recent alignment with organizations opposing such services warrants a direct conversation with the school and district to understand how those commitments actually shape practice on the ground.
See more original research from School Decision →