The top reported proficiency rate is 75% in Social studies. The lowest is 50% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Struthers Elementary School
Struthers Elementary School serves a young student population spanning pre-kindergarten through fourth grade in a working-class suburb of Youngstown. The school is situated in a historic, tree-lined neighborhood where most homes were built in the early-to-mid twentieth century. The city itself has faced long-term population decline following the loss of steel manufacturing but is now pursuing incremental revitalization focused on downtown improvements, riverfront development, and small-business support.
The school enrolls a moderate-sized student body with substantial racial and ethnic diversity. The student population is roughly two-thirds white, with meaningful representation of Hispanic, Black, and multiracial students, and a very small American Indian population. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data was not available, so a parent would want to ask the school directly about the socioeconomic composition of the student body.
On the most recent state testing data available, Struthers Elementary's proficiency rate in math was roughly three-fifths of students, placing the school below the midpoint among Mahoning County school districts when considering overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. English language arts proficiency was lower, at just under half the student population. The school achieved full participation in state testing, meaning all eligible students took the assessments. Prior social studies results from a fourth-grade cohort showed stronger performance, though this data is older and cannot be directly compared to current results given changes in testing.
The district has recently undertaken two changes that directly affect instruction at the school. In May 2022, voters approved a permanent improvement levy that replaces an expiring bond and facilities maintenance fund, meaning ongoing funding for building upkeep and repairs. Buildings in the district are older and require substantial maintenance, so this dedicated revenue stream is a concrete factor for families considering the long-term stability of school facilities. More immediately, Struthers Elementary has aligned its literacy instruction to the Science of Reading framework using CKLA curriculum, paired with Bridges for conceptual math and SAVVAS for science instruction. This curriculum shift reflects Ohio's statewide Science of Reading mandate and represents a meaningful change in how early reading is taught in the school.
Housing in Struthers is notably affordable relative to state and national benchmarks, with home values well below the Ohio average. The local economy rests on small-to-mid-size manufacturing and is part of the broader Youngstown-Warren metro labor market rather than dependent on a single employer. Parks and public transit are available, and the city library is an active civic anchor. A major new library branch is approved and under development on donated land near Yellow Creek Park, positioned as a centerpiece of the city's downtown revitalization effort.
A parent evaluating this school should understand that current test results in math and especially English language arts fall below the county midpoint. The curriculum changes now in place are intended to strengthen reading instruction going forward, so a parent may want to look into further detail with the school about how these new approaches are being implemented and what early signals of progress have emerged. The school's student body is diverse and the setting is a stable, affordable neighborhood with modest but real community investment underway. The K-4 grade band means families will transition their children to a middle school elsewhere for fifth grade and beyond.
See more original research from School Decision →