The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Social studies. The lowest is 68% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Stranahan Elementary School
Stranahan Elementary is a public elementary school in Toledo serving kindergarten through fifth grade, with an enrollment just over five hundred students. The school sits within Sylvania Schools, a suburban district currently under acute fiscal pressure following the failure of an operating levy in May 2026, which has set the stage for significant budget cuts beginning in the 2027-2028 school year. For families considering Stranahan, this district context is immediately material: proposed reductions to administrative positions, electives, and program offerings will likely reshape the school experience over the next two years.
On academics, Stranahan's most recent state testing results show proficiency in the upper-middle range against comparable schools. In English language arts, about three-quarters of tested third through fifth graders scored at proficient or above levels. In mathematics, proficiency sat somewhat lower, near two-thirds. Science proficiency was notably stronger, approaching four-fifths of tested students. These results place the school's overall proficiency index in the top quartile relative to other district schools in Lucas County, meaning Stranahan outperforms the median on the state's tested measures. The data set is recent but limited to a single year, so no trend comparability is available.
The school's student body is predominantly white, with smaller shares of students identifying as two or more races, Hispanic, and Black. About a third of enrolled students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating moderate economic diversity. The precise count of students identified as needing special education services or English language support is not available from the data provided, so parents may want to inquire directly about those populations and the supports available.
Stranahan enrolls roughly equal numbers across each grade level, with slightly higher kindergarten and fifth-grade cohorts. The school draws from a residential area in north Toledo near Sylvania and Holland, within the broader Sylvania Schools attendance zone. Housing in the area carries modest valuations by national standards and has appreciated modestly year-over-year. Rent is a realistic option for families seeking the school, with monthly rental costs running roughly a quarter of median household income for the area. The mortgage-to-income ratio sits around 3.5, making homeownership feasible for mid-range earners, though a recent Lucas County property reappraisal has increased assessed home values without proportional gains to school funding, a dynamic that has contributed to the district's fiscal strain.
Toledo itself is a mid-sized industrial city experiencing visible revitalization, particularly downtown and in mixed-use neighborhoods like the Warehouse District. The broader economy is anchored by healthcare, manufacturing, and education. Public transit via the Toledo Area Regional Transit Authority serves the city and inner suburbs with fixed-route bus service and on-demand microtransit, though much of the area remains car-dependent. This matters for school access and family logistics.
The most significant headwind facing families with children at Stranahan is the district's budget outlook. The failed levy and resulting projected expenditure cuts of roughly one billion before 2027-2028 will require difficult trade-offs. The district has already trimmed over one billion in spending during the prior several years, including teaching positions, high school counselors, and media specialists. With the May 2026 levy failure, further reductions to administrators, electives, or fees are expected. This is concrete, near-term risk to program breadth and staffing continuity that a parent should discuss directly with school and district leadership before enrolling or re-enrolling.
Separately, Sylvania Schools adopted state-approved Science of Reading instruction beginning in the 2024-2025 school year, a shift away from prior methods that all K-5 teachers completed training for by June 2025. For families familiar with older balanced-literacy approaches, this represents a meaningful change in how reading instruction works in Stranahan's primary grades.
See more original research from School Decision →