Original Research by School Decision on Tallmadge High School
Tallmadge High School serves a typical suburban high school population in a first-generation Akron suburb that developed largely in the 1950s and 1960s. The school enrolls students across four grade levels in a regular public setting. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller representations of Asian, Black, and multiracial students. A meaningful portion of the enrollment—about a quarter—qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting modest economic diversity within the district's attendance area.
On state assessments, the school shows proficiency rates in the range of mid-to-high 70s in English language arts and social studies, with science proficiency slightly above 70 percent. Math proficiency runs lower, in the mid-60s. These results represent a snapshot from the most recent school year available and reflect performance across all grade levels tested; the school has not reported multi-year trends that would show whether proficiency is moving upward or downward. Graduation rate data and chronic absenteeism figures were not available for this school. To understand where Tallmadge High sits among its peer districts in Summit County, a parent may want to ask the school or district directly for those comparisons, as state reporting on four-year cohorts and attendance patterns was not available in this review.
The school sits within the Tallmadge City School District, a district of about that size for its grade span, serving one of the area's established suburbs. The district is navigating a significant fiscal moment. A property tax levy failed in May 2026, triggering substantial cuts for the 2026-2027 school year that will touch daily operations and family logistics: high school busing will be eliminated, elementary class sizes will increase, the number of high school electives will shrink, and pay-to-participate fees will rise. Families relying on district transportation should anticipate that assumption ending. The district did approve a continuous replacement levy for facility improvements in November 2024, which provides stable funding for building maintenance and grounds upkeep without requiring repeated voter renewals.
On curriculum and pedagogy, the district has launched a district-wide shift toward what it calls "authentic learning," anchored by a Portrait of a Graduate framework and supported by new elementary and middle school buildings, a K-12 leadership team, and ongoing coaching in partnership with an external learning organization. This represents a move away from a traditional test-and-textbook model toward real-world, community-connected learning across grade levels. The high school participates in this framework, so families should expect instruction that reaches beyond standardized subjects and connects to local contexts and tangible projects.
Tallmadge itself is a car-oriented suburb organized around a historic Circle at its center and laid out in a radial street pattern with a grid beyond. The town has a diverse small-manufacturer base—mold making, metal fabrication, rubber and plastics, food processing—and remains a built-out but still-developing suburb with substantial undeveloped acreage. Housing values in the Tallmadge zip code sit slightly above the state benchmark, and rents track at a moderate level for the region. The town has limited public transit, with one regional bus route, so car ownership is practical for residents. The high school is located on a suburban campus away from the Circle, about a short drive from the town center and existing neighborhoods.
See more original research from School Decision →