The top reported proficiency rate is 31% in Social studies. The lowest is 10% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Mckinley Stemm Academy
McKinley STEMM Academy serves kindergarten through eighth grade in west Toledo, near Westland Avenue in the 43613 zip code. The school is a regular public school in the Toledo City district, not a charter or magnet school.
The student body is small, with about three hundred students distributed fairly evenly across the grade band from K through 8. The enrollment leans substantially toward Black students, with a smaller mix of white students, Hispanic students, and students identifying as two or more races. The school serves its neighborhood and does not appear to draw from a citywide application process.
State assessment data from the 2024-25 school year shows low proficiency across the subjects tested in grades 3 through 8. In mathematics, proficiency stands in single digits. In English language arts, roughly one in four students tested met state proficiency benchmarks. Science proficiency is similarly low at around three in ten. When compared to other districts across Lucas County, McKinley's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. The school participated fully in state testing, with near-universal participation across all three subjects.
The school carries a STEMM designation in its name, suggesting a focus on science, technology, engineering, mathematics, and medicine, though specific program details, course offerings, or how this focus shapes daily instruction were not available in the data reviewed. The school's location in west Toledo places it in an area experiencing active investment and development. The neighborhood around Westland is part of broader revitalization efforts across west Toledo, including the planned Westgate lifestyle center and community reinvestment initiatives that extend property tax abatements to spur new development and renovation.
It is important to note that the Toledo City district is undergoing significant structural changes. In April 2026, the board approved a major transformation plan in response to budget pressures, which includes closing and repurposing elementary schools and reconfiguring grade configurations at K-8 buildings. Parents considering this school should verify current enrollment policies and confirm what grade transitions or building changes may lie ahead, as the district's formal closure and reconfiguration announcements may affect school stability or feeder patterns. The district also recently passed a new property tax levy that marks the first operating dollars approved in over a decade, which signals an effort to stabilize and invest in schools, though restructuring remains underway.
Families looking at McKinley should understand that academic proficiency is a genuine area of concern based on recent testing, and a conversation with the school about the school's approach to improving outcomes, classroom composition, staffing, and any specialized supports or instruction tied to the STEMM focus would help clarify what resources and instructional practices are in place to address these results.
See more original research from School Decision →