Original Research by School Decision on Mayfair
Mayfair is a preschool-only program serving children in pre-K in Toledo's southern neighborhoods. The school enrolls a small cohort of children, with the student body split across Black, white, and Hispanic families, each representing meaningful shares of the enrollment.
Because Mayfair serves only pre-K, it has no state test results, graduation rate, or attendance data. Academic performance measures do not apply to this grade band. The preschool sits within Toledo City School District, which serves the broader Toledo area.
The housing market in the Mayfair neighborhood and surrounding zip code reflects moderate affordability. Home values are well below both state and national benchmarks, and monthly rent is substantially lower than the regional mortgage payment; renting is notably cheaper than buying in this area. For families considering relocation, housing costs are accessible, though the broader neighborhood context matters. Toledo is experiencing a revitalization phase, with significant downtown investment, new housing conversions, and attention from major employers in healthcare, manufacturing, and automotive sectors. The city has launched community reinvestment programs extending tax incentives for renovation and new construction into South and West Toledo, where Mayfair is located. Public transit through the Toledo Area Regional Transit Authority serves the area, though the region is largely car-dependent.
The district itself is navigating substantial change. In November 2024, voters approved a new operating levy, the first new money the district had sought in over a decade, which funds routine expenses, building maintenance, and capital projects including restoration of the Scott Park campus. More significantly, in April 2026, the Toledo Board of Education approved a major restructuring plan to address a considerable budget deficit. That plan closes and repurposes multiple elementary schools, transitions some buildings from K-8 to K-6 configuration, converts one high school to an arts focus, reconfigures another to career-technical education, reassesses district athletics, and adjusts school start times and transportation beginning in the 2026-27 school year. Families enrolling children in the district now should confirm which building assignments and configurations will apply when their child advances to elementary grades, as the landscape is shifting.
Mayfair itself operates as a regular public school and is not a charter or magnet program. The specific curriculum, classroom approach, or teacher staffing details were not available in the data, so a parent would benefit from contacting the school directly to understand its daily program, philosophy, and transition pathways to elementary school within the district's changing structure.
See more original research from School Decision →