The top reported proficiency rate is 69% in English language arts. The lowest is 50% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Toronto Elementary School
Toronto Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in a small river city in Jefferson County, about six miles north of Steubenville. The school enrolls a small-to-mid-sized population and serves a community with modest household resources: a substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the surrounding area is anchored by the TIMET titanium plant, the city's largest employer. Housing in the Toronto zip code is relatively affordable compared to state and national benchmarks, and median household income runs slightly below the national figure.
On state testing, the school's results are mixed. In English language arts and math, proficiency rates sit in the low-to-mid range. Reading proficiency is a relative strength; the school shows broader student success in that domain than in mathematics. Science proficiency, by contrast, is notably lower, sitting at about half of students meeting state standards. The school tested all eligible students in both math and English language arts, indicating strong testing participation. Among districts in Jefferson County, the school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint, a positioning that reflects decent but not exceptional academic performance within its regional peer group.
The school sits within Toronto City, a district that recently approved a significant calendar restructure for the 2026-27 school year. The district will introduce a six-week "Maymester" in May, sandwiched between two regular semesters that will end before the winter holidays. First-semester exams will move to December rather than January, and the Maymester window will offer elective courses, credit recovery, targeted math and literacy support, ACT and SAT preparation, project-based learning, STEM enrichment, and arts intensives. This is a lasting structural change that alters when grades are calculated and introduces a dedicated enrichment and intervention window parents should understand when weighing fit and pace.
The school's demographic composition is predominantly white, with a small presence of multiracial and other students. Most families live in the immediate area, in a town where historic architecture, locally owned businesses, and riverfront access create an older small-town character. The city has pursued modest housing growth tied to TIMET's expansion, including a new residential subdivision; infrastructure investments have supported both the plant and adjacent residential development, signaling modest population stabilization efforts in a historically declining area.
Science proficiency is the area where a parent may want to look into curriculum focus and instructional support with the school directly, as this result trails the other tested subjects and suggests room for strengthening in that domain. Overall, Toronto Elementary serves a rural-rooted community with working-class roots and offers elementary instruction grounded in solid participation and mid-range academic outcomes within its county context.
See more original research from School Decision →