The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 79% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Whittier Elementary School
Whittier Elementary School is a regular public elementary school in Westerville City, serving kindergarten through fifth grade in a mixed-use suburb northeast of Columbus. The school sits on Walnut Street in a neighborhood close to Uptown Westerville's historic walkable core and Otterbein University.
Student proficiency on Ohio's State Tests reflects solid performance overall. In math and English language arts, roughly four in five students in grades three through five scored at proficient or higher. Science proficiency was notably stronger, with a much higher share meeting the standard. These results position Whittier's overall proficiency index in the top quartile among elementary schools across Franklin County. The school's enrollment is diverse: a majority of students are white, but a substantial share are Black, and a meaningful portion qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school serves students across all grades relatively evenly, with the largest cohorts in kindergarten and fourth and fifth grades.
Whittier operates within the Westerville City Schools district, which has experienced real fiscal turbulence. In November 2024, voters rejected a combined bond and operating levy that would have funded facility upgrades and sustained programming. The district responded by cutting roughly 33 staff positions, reducing gifted enrichment services, and delaying renovations at four schools including work on stadium, performing arts, parking lot, and playground improvements. Parents considering the school may want to look into the current state of these programs and when facility work is expected to resume.
The district's financial picture shifted in November 2025 when voters approved a new earned income tax, a continuing levy that will generate substantial annual revenue beginning in 2026. This is a structural change in school funding: unlike property tax, it applies only to wages and net self-employment income, not to retirement income, Social Security, or pension distributions. For working families, this changes their direct tax obligation to the school district.
Another recent policy shift affects religious instruction access. The district initially rescinded its religious release time policy in 2024, ending the LifeWise Academy Bible program. It then reinstated the policy in 2025 to comply with Ohio House Bill 8, allowing students optional release for religious instruction up to one class period per week, excluding core curriculum classes.
Westerville itself is in active growth. The city center around Uptown and State Street has genuine walkability, anchored by independent shops, restaurants, and Otterbein's campus. Beyond Uptown, the built environment becomes auto-oriented, though sidewalks and bike paths support non-driving movement. Housing values in the 43081 zip code reflect a suburban market with moderate affordability for a Columbus suburb, and recent development activity includes mixed-use projects near Uptown and new subdivisions. The area has an established parks and trails system and COTA bus service, though car-dependent patterns dominate outside the historic core. Major employers include JP Morgan Chase, DHL Supply Chain, Mount Carmel Health System, and the school district itself.
For a family evaluating Whittier, the school offers solid test results within a diversified peer group, set in an area with both character and newer suburban growth. The district's recent budget cuts and then revenue recovery, along with policy shifts around gifted services and religious programming, are real factors a parent may want to discuss directly with the school to understand current resource levels and program availability.
See more original research from School Decision →