The top reported proficiency rate is 96% in Science. The lowest is 90% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Alcott Elementary School
Alcott Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in the Westerville City School District, a suburban system on the northeast edge of Columbus that spans parts of both Franklin and Delaware counties. The school sits in a community with a preserved historic downtown core built around Otterbein University, but with substantial newer residential development, and a tax base that is actively reshaping.
The most immediate context for any family evaluating Alcott is the district's recent fiscal turbulence. In November 2024, voters rejected a combined bond and operating levy, forcing the district to cut roughly a third of administrative, teaching, and support staff and reduce gifted enrichment services. Then in November 2025, voters approved an earned income tax levy that will generate ongoing revenue starting in 2026. This tax applies only to wages and self-employment income, not retirement income or other unearned sources, so its effect on household finances depends entirely on employment status. The volatility of the past year means some programming has been stripped back and staffing is thinner than it was two years ago, though the newly approved revenue stabilizes the outlook going forward.
Academically, Alcott reports strong proficiency on state testing. In the most recent assessment year, the school's students achieved proficiency in math and English language arts in the high range, with science proficiency notably higher. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among districts in Delaware County, the comparison set available. Testing participation was very high, so the results reflect the whole student population rather than a subset. However, only one year of data is available in the system, so it is not possible to see whether this performance is stable, improving, or declining.
The school enrolls a student body of modest size for an elementary school with moderate diversity. About a fifth of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The racial and ethnic makeup skews toward white students, with a smaller share identifying as Black or multiracial, and very few identifying as Asian or Hispanic. Data on the share of students receiving special education services or English learner support are not available in public reporting, so a parent interested in those details should ask the school directly.
Westerville itself is a mixed-use suburban context. The historic Uptown along State Street near Otterbein's campus has real walkability and a concentrated civic life, but most residential neighborhoods follow conventional suburban patterns built in the 1990s and 2000s. Housing values in the area are solidly above the state median, and rental costs have moderated slightly in recent months. The broader Westerville community is in an active growth phase with new subdivision activity and infill development near Uptown, so enrollment and the neighborhood character may shift over the next several years.
For a family considering Alcott, the key questions to pursue with the school directly are how the staffing reductions from the 2024 levy failure have affected classroom size and specialist availability, what the gifted program currently looks like given the reduction in facilitators, and whether the earned income tax has allowed reinstatement of any programming that was cut. The academic performance shown is solid, but one year of data is thin; asking whether the school has trend data it can share would help establish whether this level of achievement is the norm.
See more original research from School Decision →