The top reported proficiency rate is 87% in Social studies. The lowest is 0% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Harold Schnell Elementary School
Harold Schnell Elementary School serves second and third grade students in West Carrollton, a dense suburban community just outside Dayton in Montgomery County. The school is part of a district undergoing a major consolidation and rebuilding effort: a bond-funded multi-year project has replaced seven aging buildings with four new facilities. The new West Carrollton Elementary, which opened in late summer 2025, now houses all second through fourth graders, including Harold Schnell's cohort. This represents a significant operational change for families, as it reflects a complete reorganization of which building their child attends at each grade level.
The school's enrollment is small for its grade band, serving students in grades two and three exclusively. A substantial majority of the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch. The student population is racially and ethnically mixed, with roughly equal shares of white students and students of color, including significant numbers of Black and Hispanic students. The data provided do not include counts for students receiving special education services or English learners, so a parent seeking that information may want to ask the school directly.
On Ohio's State Tests for 2024–25, Harold Schnell's students in grades three and above showed proficiency rates in the mid-range. In math, about half of tested students scored at proficient or above, and in English language arts, a similar proportion met that benchmark. Participation in testing was very high. The school's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint among other elementary schools across Montgomery County districts, suggesting that while the school is open and serving its community, academic performance lags behind the county average.
Older state testing data from the school show a strong result in social studies from 2016–17, though that reflects a different grade configuration and cannot be directly compared to current performance. Science testing data from 2022–23 are limited to a single student, making them uninformative. The school has only one year of current comparable trend data, so movement over time cannot yet be assessed.
West Carrollton itself is a built-out, landlocked suburb with mid-20th-century residential architecture and limited walkability. The city's civic and recreational amenities include the Great Miami River Trail, Cox Arboretum, and community parks. A major mixed-use redevelopment called the River District is underway along the river, expected to bring new mixed-use housing, a whitewater park, and a first responder training facility. Local employment has historically centered on paper manufacturing and converting, though the sector has contracted. Housing values in the area are modest relative to national benchmarks, and rent is similarly moderate.
The school sits within a district actively reshaping its physical footprint and grade organization. Families should expect further transitions as the middle and high school facilities come online, and parents considering this school may want to understand the timeline and which building their child will attend in subsequent grades.
See more original research from School Decision →