The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Social studies. The lowest is 40% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Etna Road Elementary School
Etna Road Elementary serves grades two through five in Whitehall, a small, working-class suburb roughly six miles east of downtown Columbus. The school sits within the Whitehall City district, which has seen meaningful shifts in recent years: the district improved from a one-star to a three-star rating on the state report card between 2021 and 2024, though that gain partially reversed in 2024-25, and the district launched two new in-house Career Technical Education pathways (Medical BioScience and Engineering & Design) after years of relying on an outside program for the handful of students pursuing CTE. These moves signal a district in motion, though with uneven progress.
The student body is predominantly Black and Hispanic, with smaller shares of White and multiracial students. The enrollment is small to mid-sized for an elementary school serving this grade band. Free-and-reduced-price lunch data and counts of students with IEPs or English learner status were not available, so a parent seeking that detail would need to ask the school directly.
On state tests administered in 2024-25, proficiency rates across grades three through five ranged from around forty percent in math to roughly forty-six percent in English language arts, with science at about forty-two percent. These numbers sit below the midpoint when compared against other elementary schools in Franklin County. The participation rate was nearly universal, indicating the school is testing the students it serves rather than opting out. Trend data spanning multiple years was not available, so the direction of change—whether these results are stable, improving, or slipping—cannot be determined from the data on hand.
Whitehall itself is a car-dependent city with a commercial spine along East Broad Street and Hamilton Road. Most daily life centers on those corridors rather than a traditional downtown. Housing values have edged down slightly year-over-year, and median home prices are below the state benchmark but affordable relative to national norms; rental costs sit within the mid-range for the region. The city is in the midst of its largest reinvestment cycle in decades, with major mixed-use projects underway at the Broad and Hamilton intersection (notably the Norton Crossing development bringing apartments, retail, and a new public park) and a fifty-acre adjacent site being master-planned for hundreds of new residential units and commercial space. Population has remained roughly flat to slightly declining since 2020 despite this investment.
The school is well-positioned within Whitehall's civic geography. The Whitehall Community Park YMCA, located on North Hamilton Road, offers an indoor turf field, teaching kitchen, and youth and after-school programming tied to the school district. A public library branch sits on East Broad Street. The city has public transit via COTA bus routes, though most residents rely on personal vehicles.
The school's state test results show room for growth, particularly in math, and a parent considering Etna Road may want to look into the school's current instructional approaches in those areas. The broader district context—recent gains followed by a pullback, and noted weakness in early literacy—suggests a district making adjustments but not yet stable at high proficiency. For a family in or relocating to Whitehall, Etna Road is the established elementary option in the city's roster of schools; the question of fit turns on whether the current academic trajectory and the school's peer composition align with what a family is seeking.
See more original research from School Decision →