The top reported proficiency rate is 72% in Science. The lowest is 47% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Caldwell Elementary School
Caldwell Elementary School serves kindergarten through eighth grade in a small Appalachian village that doubles as Noble County's county seat. The school sits on Fairgrounds Road near the heart of civic life, about five hundred students in total enrollment.
The student body is predominantly white, and a substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a marker of economic challenge in the community. Enrollment trends stable across grades, with slightly larger cohorts in the lower grades. The school does not publicly report data on students with individualized education plans or English learners, which is common for schools in districts this size.
On state testing, the school's performance is mixed. In English language arts, a majority of students score at proficient levels or above. Science performance is notably stronger, with a clear majority reaching proficiency. Mathematics is the softer area: fewer than half the students tested meet proficiency standards. When positioned against the two other districts in Noble County, Caldwell Elementary's overall proficiency index sits in the bottom quartile of the county comparison. A parent looking at these results should understand that they reflect a school where some subjects have solid footing but math needs attention. The school achieved strong participation rates on state tests, suggesting reliable attendance on testing days.
The community itself is modest in scale and economically constrained. Housing values in the area are below both state and national medians, making homeownership more accessible but also signaling limited wealth. Major employers in and around Caldwell include a state prison, manufacturing plants (plastics and magnets), long-term care, and small retail, with the county's economy anchored in energy, manufacturing, and agriculture. Population has drifted down over recent decades. Recent investment has focused on downtown redevelopment rather than new housing, including conversion of historic commercial buildings to office space.
The Caldwell Exempted Village School District recently opened the Tribe Athletic Complex, a new multi-sport facility with a turf field, eight-lane track, and stadium seating, replacing an older grass field. For families, this represents a significant upgrade to athletics, physical education, and community gathering space that was previously lacking.
Caldwell Elementary is a conventional public school in a rural district serving its immediate community. It does not offer specialized programs, magnet status, or charter alternatives. For families in or relocating to the village, the school offers neighborhood access and a full K-8 span under one roof. The academic picture shows uneven performance: solid work in science and reading, but math proficiency below half the tested student body. A parent considering enrollment would want to ask the school directly about math instruction and intervention strategies, and whether the school's size and resource constraints limit course variety or specialist support.
See more original research from School Decision →