The top reported proficiency rate is 77% in Science. The lowest is 40% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carey High School
Carey High School serves grades six through twelve in a small village in northwest Ohio, drawing from a community with deep immigrant heritage and a long history centered on religious pilgrimage. The school sits in a modest-sized district that is investing in facilities—adding turf to the football field, upgrading the gymnasium, expanding elementary classroom space, and refreshing the bus fleet—but has not undergone major curriculum or operational shifts in recent years.
The school's academic profile shows a split picture. In English language arts, proficiency is solid; in science, it is notably strong. Mathematics proficiency runs lower and warrants parent attention. Social studies proficiency is high. Overall, the school's combined proficiency index across tested subjects falls at the bottom tier among the three districts in Wyandot County, so parents comparing performance within the county will see Carey trailing its neighbors. The state test data available here covers grades three through eight; high school course-level assessments or AP and dual-credit offerings were not available in the materials provided, so a reader evaluating college-preparatory pathways should ask the school directly about those.
The student body is small to mid-sized for its grade band and is overwhelmingly white, with very limited racial and ethnic diversity. Roughly a third of the enrollment qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, pointing to a community with modest but not acute economic stress. Special education enrollment and English learner data were not reported.
Carey itself is a compact village with a traditional grid layout, tree-lined residential streets, and a small downtown anchored by the Basilica and National Shrine of Our Lady of Consolation, which draws thousands of pilgrims annually. Population has drifted slowly downward over recent decades, settling at a small figure in the 2020 census. Housing values in the area are well below the state median and notably below the national benchmark, making homeownership relatively affordable for families in this income bracket. Median mortgage estimates suggest monthly payments well below what families in higher-cost regions would face. The local economy rests on manufacturing and industrial employers—National Lime and Stone, Continental Structural Plastics, Hanon Systems, and smaller utility and fabrication firms—alongside the school district and a Catholic school as significant employers. There is no public transit; the village's civic anchors include its library, parks including a recently opened inclusive playground, and outdoor preserves nearby.
The school's setting is rural and insular. A parent moving here or enrolling a child would find themselves in a tight-knit, stable community with industrial character, limited racial or ethnic diversity, and academic performance that is mixed: competent in reading and strong in science, but softer in math and in overall position relative to county peers. The progression through middle and high school is housed under one roof, which simplifies administration but may or may not align with a family's preference for separate middle and high school environments.
See more original research from School Decision →