The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Math. The lowest is 84% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Coldwater Elementary School
Coldwater Elementary serves kindergarten through fourth grade in a small, rural village of west-central Ohio. The school enrolls about six hundred thirty students drawn almost entirely from the immediate area, which is predominantly white and rooted in agriculture, small manufacturing, and healthcare. The school sits on a consolidated campus shared with the middle and high schools, a short distance from the downtown core.
On state assessment, the school shows solid performance. In the most recent testing year, students across grades three and four scored at proficiency levels above the midpoint when compared to other districts in Mercer County. Math proficiency was stronger than English language arts, with the vast majority of tested students meeting or exceeding state standards in both. A social studies assessment from several years prior also showed strong performance at the fourth-grade level. Only one year of data was available for the comparison, so trend information was not provided and the reading does not reflect whether performance has risen or fallen in recent years.
The school's proficiency index places it above the midpoint among its county's districts, a meaningful position in a rural region where school quality varies. Notably, the data presented does not include free-or-reduced-price lunch counts, special education identification rates, English learner enrollment, chronic absenteeism, or discipline records. Absence of these fields may reflect the school's small size, the nature of the data collection, or the grade band served. A parent seeking information on how the school supports students with gaps, identifies and serves students with disabilities, or addresses attendance should contact the school directly.
The parent environment reflects recent fiscal strain. In May 2025, after two prior failed attempts, voters approved a five-year additional local income tax increase for the schools. This will raise household tax burden for families in the district while funding aging facilities and instructional materials the district indicated were at risk. That context matters: the school appears well-run on measures of core academics, but operates within a district that has faced budget pressure serious enough to require a third levy campaign to close a structural gap. Parents should understand that this reflects real infrastructure and staffing concerns the district leadership identified as unmet without the new revenue.
The village itself is tight-knit, rooted in faith and family, with a small downtown and a strong civic culture centered on Coldwater Memorial Park and an annual community picnic. Major employers include a county hospital, poultry processors, promotional products makers, and light manufacturing. The housing market is modestly priced below the state benchmark, and employment has declined slightly in recent years. This is a stable, slowly growing rural place with limited growth on the horizon.
For families seeking a small, academically solid elementary school in a tight-knit rural community with strong performance on state tests, Coldwater Elementary fits that profile. For families needing detailed information on special education, English learner support, or school-climate measures, direct conversation with the school is warranted, as those details were not available in this data.
See more original research from School Decision →