The top reported proficiency rate is 61% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Mckinley Elementary School
Mckinley Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Fairport Harbor, a small lakefront village about thirty miles northeast of Cleveland at the mouth of the Grand River on Lake Erie. The school sits within the Fairport Harbor Exempted Village School District, which recently underwent a transformative consolidation. As of January 2026, the district moved students into a new unified PreK-12 campus on the Harding site, merging separate aging elementary and middle/high school buildings into a single modern facility. For families in the McKinley attendance zone, this means students now move through a cohesive, newly constructed learning environment from early childhood through graduation, rather than transitioning between older buildings.
The enrollment is small, with about a quarter of a thousand students across all grades. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting economic conditions in this commuter community where major local employment centers around the working port and salt operations, and where residents often work in sales, healthcare, and administrative roles elsewhere in the county and greater Cleveland. Racially and ethnically, the school is predominantly white, with smaller populations of Hispanic, multiracial, and Black students.
State assessment results from the most recent testing show reading proficiency at about half of students in grades three through five, while math proficiency falls below that, at about four in ten. Science proficiency was lower still, below four in ten on the available data. These results position the school in the bottom quartile for overall proficiency when compared to other districts in Lake County. In prior testing from 2016-17, fourth-grade social studies proficiency reached about six in ten, suggesting some variation across subjects and years, though recent data shows a dip in core academics. A parent may want to discuss these results directly with the school to understand what instructional priorities or supports are in place and what the trajectory looks like moving forward.
Fairport Harbor itself is a compact, walkable village of historic character with locally-owned downtown shops, dining, and beach access, functioning largely as a residential commuter community today. The opening of the new unified school campus is a significant anchor development for the district and the town. Housing in the zip code is modestly valued and rents are reasonable relative to national benchmarks. For families considering the area, Mckinley offers the stability of a small, settled community school and access to a brand-new building that consolidates the district's educational footprint. The academic performance data warrants direct conversation with school leadership about instruction and support, particularly in math and reading.
See more original research from School Decision →